20-quarter listed-company comparison

Insurance - Property & Casualty Stocks

Insurance - Property & Casualty: The Allstate Corporation owns the largest revenue base; White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. has the fastest current growth.

The industry itself · before any single company

How has Insurance - Property & Casualty moved against S&P 500?

The line below covers 5.2 years. Over the most recent two of them this industry is 16% ahead of S&P 500. Earnings across its companies grew 34% on average over the last four reported quarters. It has been ahead of S&P 500 on a rolling three-month view for 6 weeks running.

BREAKING OUT · ahead 6w✓Price and the fundamentals both up33 of 44 companies ahead of S&P 500 by 5% or more over three months4 are 20% or more behind over a year while earnings grew 20% or more

RS ↑6w · 36/44 >200d (+0) · 33/44 lead (+15) · EPS 39/44↑

Insurance - Property & Casualty, equal-weighted, based at 200 S&P 500, same base, same start trailing 12-month earnings per share rising falling

Strength anatomy Broadening down the ladderHow much of the industry is participating, how recently, and whether the movers score well.

Together33 of 44 stocks moving

Fresh15 crossed in the last 4 weeks

Backed by scoresmovers score +2 vs the industry average

Down the cap ladder — bar is now, tick is four weeks ago

Large 8/9+5

Mid 15/16+8

Small 10/19+2

Participation is spreading downward — the mid and small companies added more this month than the large ones did.

Both lines start at 200 in the same week, so the distance between them is the whole story: the industry line is an equal-weighted index of its 44 companies. The bars underneath are trailing 12-month earnings per share, one bar per reported quarter, each member rebased to 100 at the start and the industry taking the median — so a price line pulling away from flat bars is a re-rating, not earnings. A bar turns red when that figure is lower than the quarter before. Rules are fixed and applied identically everywhere on this site: ahead by 5% or more over three months, or behind by 20% or more over a year while earnings grew 20% or more. Hover any point to read both values and the gap. This is a description of what the numbers did, not advice.

Sector relative strength · before individual stocks

Is Insurance - Property & Casualty outperforming S&P 500?

Insurance - Property & Casualty has outperformed S&P 500 by 6.4% over the last 52 weeks. Over 13 weeks the gap is a lead of 14.1%. 20 of 30 covered companies currently beat the S&P 500 on Mansfield relative strength, so leadership inside the sector is selective. United Fire Group, Inc. is the strongest against the sector itself at +18.7%.

+14.1%Sector vs S&P 500 · 13 weeks

+6.4%Sector vs S&P 500 · 52 weeks

20/30Stocks leading S&P 500

12/30Stocks leading sector

Sector metric: — as of latest available · unclassified · direction unavailable.

The central tension: the companies with the most scale are not necessarily the companies creating the most change.

Start with scale. Then earnings trajectory. Then business quality. Only after those three agree should price leadership carry much weight.

Bottom line

Insurance - Property & Casualty has outperformed S&P 500 by 6.4% over 52 weeks and 14.1% over 13 weeks. 20 of 30 covered companies beat the S&P 500 on Mansfield relative strength, while 12 of 30 beat the sector itself. The Allstate Corporation leads with income of $68,174 million, based on 21 of 30 comparable companies through Mar 2026.

Is the Insurance - Property & Casualty sector outperforming S&P 500?

Which Insurance - Property & Casualty company is largest by income?

The Allstate Corporation leads with income of $68,174 million, based on 21 of 30 comparable companies through Mar 2026.

Which Insurance - Property & Casualty company is growing fastest?

White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. has the fastest current income growth at 69.3%, across 21 of 30 comparable companies.

Which Insurance - Property & Casualty company has the strongest 4-Factor Sector Score?

Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. ranks first at 75.4/100 with 70% evidence confidence. The score prioritizes research; it is not a buy recommendation.

Which Insurance - Property & Casualty company has the lowest comparable P/BV-to-ROE?

Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. has the lowest comparable P/BV ÷ ROE at 0.11, among 23 of 30 companies that pass the metric’s comparability rules.

How much history does this Insurance - Property & Casualty comparison include?

The page compares up to 20 reported quarters per company for fundamentals, CAPEX, debt and valuation, ending Jun 2026. Missing observations remain blank rather than being estimated.

How is the 4-Factor Sector Score calculated?

The four visible contributions add directly: growth and earnings up to 35 points, capital efficiency up to 25, valuation up to 20, and relative strength up to 20. Missing or stale evidence moves only the affected contribution toward neutral.

Companies

complete canonical membership

Combined market value

$650.0B

Chubb Limited

Revenue growing

20/21

positive TTM year-on-year growth

Beating S&P 500

20/30

positive Mansfield relative strength

Global company selection

00 · research priority, made explicit

4-Factor Sector Score

An additive sector-relative research score. The four displayed point contributions always equal the total: Growth & earnings (35), Capital efficiency (25), Valuation (20), and Relative strength (20). Missing or stale evidence is absorbed inside the affected factor, never applied as a hidden adjustment.

Growth & earnings · 35%Capital efficiency · 25%Valuation · 20%Relative strength · 20%

Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. has the strongest current balance of earnings trajectory, business quality, valuation and price confirmation, with 70% evidence confidence.

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. has stronger price confirmation than earnings confirmation; that is a research prompt, not permission to chase.

Missing observations are not scored as bad. Their missing weight lowers confidence and pulls the final score toward neutral. Financial companies use P/BV÷ROE and asset quality; PEG, industrial OPM and ROCE are excluded.

1. Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. · SLDE

75.4/100 · Favorable setup · 70% evidence

Exact sum: 24.7 + 20.8 + 14.5 + 15.4 = 75.4

Decision use: Confirmed research leader: earnings, capital efficiency and relative strength agree. Move to management, catalyst and risk diligence.

24.7/35Growth & earnings

Income 36.1% · PAT 100%

71% evidence

20.8/25Capital efficiency

ROA 5.8% · ROE 17% · GNPA —

68% evidence

14.5/20Valuation

P/BV 1.9× · P/BV÷ROE 0.11

70% evidence

15.4/20Relative strength

RS sector 7.2% · RS bench 15.4% · 1Y 17%

70% evidence

2. The Allstate Corporation · ALL

69.4/100 · Favorable setup · 76% evidence

Exact sum: 23.7 + 15.6 + 12.1 + 18 = 69.4

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

23.7/35Growth & earnings

Income 4.4% · PAT 100%

71% evidence

15.6/25Capital efficiency

ROA 2.1% · ROE 9.2% · GNPA —

68% evidence

12.1/20Valuation

P/BV 1.69× · P/BV÷ROE 0.18

70% evidence

18.0/20Relative strength

RS sector 10.9% · RS bench 19.3% · 1Y 36.4%

100% evidence

3. The Travelers Companies, Inc. · TRV

61.4/100 · Mixed-positive evidence · 60% evidence

Exact sum: 19.9 + 15 + 7.8 + 18.7 = 61.4

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

19.9/35Growth & earnings

Income — · PAT —

26% evidence

15.0/25Capital efficiency

ROA 1.6% · ROE 7% · GNPA —

68% evidence

7.8/20Valuation

P/BV 2.08× · P/BV÷ROE 0.3

70% evidence

18.7/20Relative strength

RS sector 16.2% · RS bench 25% · 1Y 53.8%

100% evidence

4. Mercury General Corporation · MCY

58.6/100 · Mixed-positive evidence · 67% evidence

Exact sum: 21.7 + 15.1 + 10.2 + 11.6 = 58.6

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

21.7/35Growth & earnings

Income 9.7% · PAT 100%

45% evidence

15.1/25Capital efficiency

ROA 2.1% · ROE 8.6% · GNPA —

68% evidence

10.2/20Valuation

P/BV 1.89× · P/BV÷ROE 0.22

70% evidence

11.6/20Relative strength

RS sector 4.3% · RS bench 12.4% · 1Y 60.9%

100% evidence

5. Skyward Specialty Insurance Group, Inc. · SKWD

57.5/100 · Mixed-positive evidence · 76% evidence

Exact sum: 19.5 + 12.2 + 6.7 + 19.1 = 57.5

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

19.5/35Growth & earnings

Income 28.9% · PAT 43.5%

71% evidence

12.2/25Capital efficiency

ROA 1.1% · ROE 4.8% · GNPA —

68% evidence

6.7/20Valuation

P/BV 1.59× · P/BV÷ROE 0.33

70% evidence

19.1/20Relative strength

RS sector 12.3% · RS bench 20.6% · 1Y 27.1%

100% evidence

6. United Fire Group, Inc. · UFCS

57.4/100 · Mixed-positive evidence · 70% evidence

Exact sum: 22.3 + 9.8 + 8.3 + 17 = 57.4

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

22.3/35Growth & earnings

Income 10.6% · PAT 97%

71% evidence

9.8/25Capital efficiency

ROA 0.9% · ROE 3.4% · GNPA —

68% evidence

8.3/20Valuation

P/BV 1× · P/BV÷ROE 0.29

70% evidence

17.0/20Relative strength

RS sector 18.7% · RS bench 28% · 1Y 102.1%

70% evidence

7. W. R. Berkley Corporation · WRB

56.4/100 · Mixed-positive evidence · 60% evidence

Exact sum: 21.4 + 17.9 + 8.6 + 8.5 = 56.4

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

21.4/35Growth & earnings

Income — · PAT —

26% evidence

17.9/25Capital efficiency

ROA 2.2% · ROE 9.7% · GNPA —

68% evidence

8.6/20Valuation

P/BV 2.54× · P/BV÷ROE 0.26

70% evidence

8.5/20Relative strength

RS sector -6.6% · RS bench 0.3% · 1Y 10%

100% evidence

8. The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. · THG

56.2/100 · Mixed-positive evidence · 76% evidence

Exact sum: 20.4 + 12.9 + 7.7 + 15.2 = 56.2

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

20.4/35Growth & earnings

Income 6.4% · PAT 64.8%

71% evidence

12.9/25Capital efficiency

ROA 1.2% · ROE 5.6% · GNPA —

68% evidence

7.7/20Valuation

P/BV 1.7× · P/BV÷ROE 0.3

70% evidence

15.2/20Relative strength

RS sector 5.8% · RS bench 13.8% · 1Y 32.8%

100% evidence

9. RLI Corp. · RLI

54.7/100 · Mixed-positive evidence · 60% evidence

Exact sum: 20.5 + 17.7 + 6.6 + 9.9 = 54.7

Decision use: Strong business, demanding price: keep it on the quality list, but require either earnings upgrades or valuation compression.

20.5/35Growth & earnings

Income — · PAT —

26% evidence

17.7/25Capital efficiency

ROA 2.7% · ROE 9.6% · GNPA —

68% evidence

6.6/20Valuation

P/BV 3.09× · P/BV÷ROE 0.32

70% evidence

9.9/20Relative strength

RS sector -6.8% · RS bench 0% · 1Y -1.2%

100% evidence

10. HCI Group, Inc. · HCI

53.9/100 · Mixed-positive evidence · 62% evidence

Exact sum: 22.2 + 13.9 + 11.6 + 6.2 = 53.9

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

22.2/35Growth & earnings

Income 22.1% · PAT 100%

55% evidence

13.9/25Capital efficiency

ROA — · ROE 9.9% · GNPA —

34% evidence

11.6/20Valuation

P/BV 1.83× · P/BV÷ROE 0.18

70% evidence

6.2/20Relative strength

RS sector -9.1% · RS bench -2.3% · 1Y 29.1%

100% evidence

11. Porch Group, Inc. · PRCH

52.8/100 · Thin evidence · provisional · 55% evidence

Exact sum: 20.3 + 11.6 + 9.8 + 11.1 = 52.8

Decision use: Fill the missing evidence before acting; the ranking is deliberately pulled toward neutral.

20.3/35Growth & earnings

Income 16.6% · PAT —

45% evidence

11.6/25Capital efficiency

ROA 2.2% · ROE -67.4% · GNPA —

68% evidence

9.8/20Valuation

P/BV -29.88× · P/BV÷ROE —

10% evidence

11.1/20Relative strength

RS sector -3.5% · RS bench 3.3% · 1Y 2.7%

100% evidence

12. Assurant, Inc. · AIZ

52.6/100 · Mixed-positive evidence · 76% evidence

Exact sum: 21.1 + 11.3 + 5.9 + 14.3 = 52.6

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

21.1/35Growth & earnings

Income 9% · PAT 49%

71% evidence

11.3/25Capital efficiency

ROA 0.8% · ROE 4.9% · GNPA —

68% evidence

5.9/20Valuation

P/BV 1.84× · P/BV÷ROE 0.38

70% evidence

14.3/20Relative strength

RS sector 5.2% · RS bench 13.3% · 1Y 51.8%

100% evidence

13. Palomar Holdings, Inc. · PLMR

52.1/100 · Mixed-positive evidence · 62% evidence

Exact sum: 21.7 + 12.2 + 3.5 + 14.7 = 52.1

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

21.7/35Growth & earnings

Income 60.4% · PAT 47%

55% evidence

12.2/25Capital efficiency

ROA — · ROE 4.9% · GNPA —

34% evidence

3.5/20Valuation

P/BV 3.3× · P/BV÷ROE 0.67

70% evidence

14.7/20Relative strength

RS sector 0.7% · RS bench 8.2% · 1Y 10.4%

100% evidence

14. Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. · KNSL

48.0/100 · Mixed-negative evidence · 60% evidence

Exact sum: 18.6 + 18.3 + 5.1 + 6 = 48

Decision use: Strong business, demanding price: keep it on the quality list, but require either earnings upgrades or valuation compression.

18.6/35Growth & earnings

Income — · PAT —

26% evidence

18.3/25Capital efficiency

ROA 3% · ROE 9.4% · GNPA —

68% evidence

5.1/20Valuation

P/BV 3.69× · P/BV÷ROE 0.39

70% evidence

6.0/20Relative strength

RS sector -15.7% · RS bench -9.6% · 1Y -16.7%

100% evidence

15. Old Republic International Corporation · ORI

45.6/100 · Mixed-negative evidence · 60% evidence

Exact sum: 20 + 12.3 + 7.4 + 5.9 = 45.6

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

20.0/35Growth & earnings

Income — · PAT —

26% evidence

12.3/25Capital efficiency

ROA 1.1% · ROE 5.3% · GNPA —

68% evidence

7.4/20Valuation

P/BV 1.64× · P/BV÷ROE 0.31

70% evidence

5.9/20Relative strength

RS sector -6.8% · RS bench 0.1% · 1Y 23.7%

100% evidence

16. The Progressive Corporation · PGR

44.6/100 · Mixed-negative evidence · 60% evidence

Exact sum: 15.1 + 18.3 + 5.6 + 5.6 = 44.6

Decision use: Strong business, demanding price: keep it on the quality list, but require either earnings upgrades or valuation compression.

15.1/35Growth & earnings

Income — · PAT —

26% evidence

18.3/25Capital efficiency

ROA 2.8% · ROE 9.9% · GNPA —

68% evidence

5.6/20Valuation

P/BV 3.61× · P/BV÷ROE 0.36

70% evidence

5.6/20Relative strength

RS sector -12.8% · RS bench -6.4% · 1Y -8.9%

100% evidence

17. Selective Insurance Group, Inc. · SIGI

44.3/100 · Mixed-negative evidence · 60% evidence

Exact sum: 18.2 + 10.8 + 5.3 + 10 = 44.3

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

18.2/35Growth & earnings

Income — · PAT —

26% evidence

10.8/25Capital efficiency

ROA 0.9% · ROE 3.7% · GNPA —

68% evidence

5.3/20Valuation

P/BV 1.59× · P/BV÷ROE 0.43

70% evidence

10.0/20Relative strength

RS sector -2% · RS bench 5.5% · 1Y 21.9%

100% evidence

18. Cincinnati Financial Corporation · CINF

42.4/100 · Mixed-negative evidence · 67% evidence

Exact sum: 22.9 + 8.2 + 3.8 + 7.5 = 42.4

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

22.9/35Growth & earnings

Income 17.9% · PAT 90.5%

45% evidence

8.2/25Capital efficiency

ROA 0.7% · ROE 1.9% · GNPA —

68% evidence

3.8/20Valuation

P/BV 1.55× · P/BV÷ROE 0.81

70% evidence

7.5/20Relative strength

RS sector -3.5% · RS bench 3.8% · 1Y 24.9%

100% evidence

19. Chubb Limited · CB

42.4/100 · Mixed-negative evidence · 60% evidence

Exact sum: 14.9 + 12.2 + 4.9 + 10.4 = 42.4

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

14.9/35Growth & earnings

Income — · PAT —

26% evidence

12.2/25Capital efficiency

ROA 1.1% · ROE 3.7% · GNPA —

68% evidence

4.9/20Valuation

P/BV 1.75× · P/BV÷ROE 0.47

70% evidence

10.4/20Relative strength

RS sector 1.2% · RS bench 8.9% · 1Y 35.9%

100% evidence

20. Safety Insurance Group, Inc. · SAFT

41.9/100 · Thin evidence · provisional · 58% evidence

Exact sum: 9.6 + 5.8 + 9.8 + 16.7 = 41.9

Decision use: Fill the missing evidence before acting; the ranking is deliberately pulled toward neutral.

9.6/35Growth & earnings

Income 10.8% · PAT -13.7%

71% evidence

5.8/25Capital efficiency

ROA -0.6% · ROE -1.7% · GNPA —

68% evidence

9.8/20Valuation

P/BV 1.25× · P/BV÷ROE —

10% evidence

16.7/20Relative strength

RS sector 18.5% · RS bench 27.3% · 1Y 48.7%

70% evidence

21. White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. · WTM

41.2/100 · Mixed-negative evidence · 64% evidence

Exact sum: 21.3 + 6 + 9.8 + 4.1 = 41.2

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

21.3/35Growth & earnings

Income 69.3% · PAT 100%

71% evidence

6.0/25Capital efficiency

ROA 0% · ROE -0.5% · GNPA —

68% evidence

9.8/20Valuation

P/BV 1.01× · P/BV÷ROE —

10% evidence

4.1/20Relative strength

RS sector -6.8% · RS bench 0.3% · 1Y 24.1%

100% evidence

22. Horace Mann Educators Corporation · HMN

40.0/100 · Mixed-negative evidence · 76% evidence

Exact sum: 16.8 + 7.8 + 5.5 + 9.9 = 40

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

16.8/35Growth & earnings

Income 5.5% · PAT 43.9%

71% evidence

7.8/25Capital efficiency

ROA 0.3% · ROE 2.9% · GNPA —

68% evidence

5.5/20Valuation

P/BV 1.17× · P/BV÷ROE 0.4

70% evidence

9.9/20Relative strength

RS sector -0.7% · RS bench 6.8% · 1Y 27.2%

100% evidence

23. CNA Financial Corporation · CNA

39.6/100 · Mixed-negative evidence · 76% evidence

Exact sum: 13.8 + 8 + 4.5 + 13.3 = 39.6

Decision use: Price leads the evidence: RS versus the benchmark is 9.1%, but earnings trajectory is weak. Wait for revenue and profit confirmation.

13.8/35Growth & earnings

Income 4% · PAT 35.8%

71% evidence

8.0/25Capital efficiency

ROA 0.3% · ROE 2% · GNPA —

68% evidence

4.5/20Valuation

P/BV 1.14× · P/BV÷ROE 0.57

70% evidence

13.3/20Relative strength

RS sector 1.6% · RS bench 9.1% · 1Y 26%

100% evidence

24. Lemonade, Inc. · LMND

38.6/100 · Thin evidence · provisional · 55% evidence

Exact sum: 24.4 + 4.1 + 9 + 1.1 = 38.6

Decision use: Fill the missing evidence before acting; the ranking is deliberately pulled toward neutral.

24.4/35Growth & earnings

Income 51.2% · PAT —

45% evidence

4.1/25Capital efficiency

ROA -1.9% · ROE -6.7% · GNPA —

68% evidence

9.0/20Valuation

P/BV 9.29× · P/BV÷ROE —

10% evidence

1.1/20Relative strength

RS sector -14.8% · RS bench -8.4% · 1Y 70.6%

100% evidence

25. Stewart Information Services Corporation · STC

36.8/100 · Mixed-negative evidence · 60% evidence

Exact sum: 17.4 + 13.2 + 5.1 + 1.1 = 36.8

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

17.4/35Growth & earnings

Income — · PAT —

26% evidence

13.2/25Capital efficiency

ROA 1.6% · ROE 2.7% · GNPA —

68% evidence

5.1/20Valuation

P/BV 1.21× · P/BV÷ROE 0.45

70% evidence

1.1/20Relative strength

RS sector -13.2% · RS bench -6.7% · 1Y 5.9%

100% evidence

26. Loews Corporation · L

34.6/100 · Adverse evidence · 76% evidence

Exact sum: 14.3 + 8.1 + 4.2 + 8 = 34.6

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

14.3/35Growth & earnings

Income 4.2% · PAT 23.8%

71% evidence

8.1/25Capital efficiency

ROA 0.5% · ROE 1.9% · GNPA —

68% evidence

4.2/20Valuation

P/BV 1.17× · P/BV÷ROE 0.62

70% evidence

8.0/20Relative strength

RS sector -2.1% · RS bench 5.3% · 1Y 32.2%

100% evidence

27. Hagerty, Inc. · HGTY

31.8/100 · Adverse evidence · 64% evidence

Exact sum: 12.8 + 4.9 + 9.1 + 5 = 31.8

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

12.8/35Growth & earnings

Income 15.4% · PAT 12.4%

71% evidence

4.9/25Capital efficiency

ROA -0.6% · ROE -2.2% · GNPA —

68% evidence

9.1/20Valuation

P/BV 4.87× · P/BV÷ROE —

10% evidence

5.0/20Relative strength

RS sector -10.1% · RS bench -3.5% · 1Y 21.4%

100% evidence

28. Markel Group Inc. · MKL

31.5/100 · Adverse evidence · 64% evidence

Exact sum: 10.2 + 6 + 9.8 + 5.5 = 31.5

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

10.2/35Growth & earnings

Income 9.7% · PAT -5.6%

71% evidence

6.0/25Capital efficiency

ROA -0.3% · ROE -1.1% · GNPA —

68% evidence

9.8/20Valuation

P/BV 1.32× · P/BV÷ROE —

10% evidence

5.5/20Relative strength

RS sector -10.5% · RS bench -3.8% · 1Y 5.7%

100% evidence

29. American Financial Group, Inc. · AFG

30.9/100 · Adverse evidence · 76% evidence

Exact sum: 12.1 + 10.1 + 4.4 + 4.3 = 30.9

Decision use: Balanced evidence: keep at normal research priority and require another comparable period before raising conviction.

12.1/35Growth & earnings

Income -1.2% · PAT 10%

71% evidence

10.1/25Capital efficiency

ROA 0.6% · ROE 4.2% · GNPA —

68% evidence

4.4/20Valuation

P/BV 2.27× · P/BV÷ROE 0.54

70% evidence

4.3/20Relative strength

RS sector -7% · RS bench 0% · 1Y 18.3%

100% evidence

30. Kemper Corporation · KMPR

24.7/100 · Thin evidence · provisional · 58% evidence

Exact sum: 6.1 + 5.8 + 9.8 + 3 = 24.7

Decision use: Fill the missing evidence before acting; the ranking is deliberately pulled toward neutral.

6.1/35Growth & earnings

Income 0.3% · PAT -90.6%

71% evidence

5.8/25Capital efficiency

ROA 0% · ROE -0.2% · GNPA —

68% evidence

9.8/20Valuation

P/BV 0.68× · P/BV÷ROE —

10% evidence

3.0/20Relative strength

RS sector -29% · RS bench -24% · 1Y -48.5%

70% evidence

01 · compare level, then change

Income Scale & Growth Durability

The Allstate Corporation has the highest Income among the 30 Insurance - Property & Casualty companies compared here, at $68,174 million. Loews Corporation is next at $18,515 million. White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. has the highest Income growth at 69.3%, so level and change sit with different companies. Its Income series carries 19 reported observations across the 20-quarter window.

What the numbers say: The Allstate Corporation is the scale leader at $68,174 million, 268.2% ahead of Loews Corporation. White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd.'s growth is 69.3% from a $3,675 million base, with 19 reported observations in the 20-quarter window. Treat the growth leader as an acceleration candidate, not as equally proven scale.

LeaderThe Allstate Corporation · $68,174 million

Gap268.2% versus #2 · Loews Corporation

Persistence8/8 recent comparable periods

Coverage21/30 companies · 564 observations

Investor read: The Allstate Corporation is the scale benchmark; White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. is the acceleration watch. Promote the challenger only if growth persists and converts into margin and returns.

This conclusion weakens if: The Allstate Corporation's growth falls below White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd.'s for two consecutive comparable reports while operating margin also compresses.

For lenders, reported income is used instead of industrial-company sales. Growth is compared year-on-year.

Incomelargest

1The Allstate Corporation ALL$68.2B

2Loews Corporation L$18.5B

3Markel Group Inc. MKL$16.1B

4CNA Financial Corporation CNA$15.0B

5Assurant, Inc. AIZ$13.2B

Income growthfastest growers

1White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. WTM69%

2Palomar Holdings, Inc. PLMR60%

3Lemonade, Inc. LMND51%

4Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. SLDE36%

5Skyward Specialty Insurance Group, Inc. SKWD29%

Income · company comparison

21/30 level · 21/30 change

Solid lines show level; dotted lines show change when “Both” is selected. Missing reports break the line rather than being invented.

All-company data · latest reported quarter

Each figure is the company’s latest single reported quarter. The rankings above use trailing-twelve-month or current-market values, so a company can legitimately show a different number in each.

Company	Income	Income growth	Reported
The Progressive Corporation PGR	$22.2B	8.7%	Jun 2026
The Allstate Corporation ALL	$16.9B	3.0%	Mar 2026
Chubb Limited CB	$14.8B	11%	Jun 2026
The Travelers Companies, Inc. TRV	$11.9B	1.0%	Jun 2026
Loews Corporation L	$4.6B	1.4%	Mar 2026
W. R. Berkley Corporation WRB	$3.7B	4.0%	Jun 2026
CNA Financial Corporation CNA	$3.7B	1.4%	Mar 2026
Markel Group Inc. MKL	$3.6B	0.1%	Mar 2026
Assurant, Inc. AIZ	$3.4B	11%	Mar 2026
Cincinnati Financial Corporation CINF	$2.9B	12%	Mar 2026
Old Republic International Corporation ORI	$2.4B	13%	Jun 2026
American Financial Group, Inc. AFG	$1.9B	-0.1%	Mar 2026
The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. THG	$1.7B	6.1%	Mar 2026
Mercury General Corporation MCY	$1.5B	10%	Mar 2026
Selective Insurance Group, Inc. SIGI	$1.4B	5.8%	Jun 2026
Kemper Corporation KMPR	$1.1B	-7.2%	Mar 2026
Stewart Information Services Corporation STC	$781M	28%	Jun 2026
White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. WTM	$518M	-10%	Mar 2026
Skyward Specialty Insurance Group, Inc. SKWD	$476M	45%	Mar 2026
Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. KNSL	$467M	10%	Jun 2026
Horace Mann Educators Corporation HMN	$429M	3.1%	Mar 2026
RLI Corp. RLI	$424M	3.9%	Jun 2026
Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. SLDE	$389M	38%	Mar 2026
United Fire Group, Inc. UFCS	$369M	11%	Mar 2026
Safety Insurance Group, Inc. SAFT	$315M	4.7%	Mar 2026
Hagerty, Inc. HGTY	$312M	-4.9%	Mar 2026
Palomar Holdings, Inc. PLMR	$279M	59%	Mar 2026
Lemonade, Inc. LMND	$258M	71%	Mar 2026
HCI Group, Inc. HCI	$243M	13%	Mar 2026
Porch Group, Inc. PRCH	$121M	15%	Mar 2026

Full 20-quarter history · every available company

Income · reported quarter history

Showing the 12 largest of 30 companies with a series here. The remaining 18 are complete in the plain-text rendition and the trace payload — nothing is dropped from the data, only from this grid.

American Financial Group, Inc. · AFG

Sep 2021$1.8B

Dec 2021$1.8B

Mar 2022$1.6B

Jun 2022$1.5B

Sep 2022$2.0B

Dec 2022$1.9B

Mar 2023$1.7B

Jun 2023$1.8B

Sep 2023$2.2B

Dec 2023$2.1B

Mar 2024$1.9B

Jun 2024$1.9B

Sep 2024$2.4B

Dec 2024$2.1B

Mar 2025$1.9B

Jun 2025$1.9B

Sep 2025$2.3B

Dec 2025$2.1B

Mar 2026$1.9B

Jun 2026—

Assurant, Inc. · AIZ

Sep 2021$2.6B

Dec 2021$2.6B

Mar 2022$2.5B

Jun 2022$2.5B

Sep 2022$2.5B

Dec 2022$2.7B

Mar 2023$2.6B

Jun 2023$2.7B

Sep 2023$2.8B

Dec 2023$3.0B

Mar 2024$2.9B

Jun 2024$2.9B

Sep 2024$3.0B

Dec 2024$3.1B

Mar 2025$3.1B

Jun 2025$3.2B

Sep 2025$3.2B

Dec 2025$3.4B

Mar 2026$3.4B

Jun 2026—

Chubb Limited · CB

Sep 2021$10.8B

Dec 2021$10.8B

Mar 2022$9.6B

Jun 2022$9.9B

Sep 2022$12.1B

Dec 2022$11.3B

Mar 2023$11.1B

Jun 2023$11.8B

Sep 2023$13.9B

Dec 2023$13.3B

Mar 2024$12.9B

Jun 2024$13.8B

Sep 2024$14.8B

Dec 2024$14.6B

Mar 2025$13.4B

Jun 2025$15.5B

Sep 2025$16.2B

Dec 2025$15.6B

Mar 2026$14.8B

Jun 2026—

Cincinnati Financial Corporation · CINF

Sep 2021$1.8B

Dec 2021$3.3B

Mar 2022$1.2B

Jun 2022$820M

Sep 2022$1.4B

Dec 2022$3.1B

Mar 2023$2.2B

Jun 2023$2.6B

Sep 2023$1.8B

Dec 2023$3.4B

Mar 2024$2.9B

Jun 2024$2.5B

Sep 2024$3.3B

Dec 2024$2.5B

Mar 2025$2.6B

Jun 2025$3.2B

Sep 2025$3.7B

Dec 2025$3.1B

Mar 2026$2.9B

Jun 2026—

CNA Financial Corporation · CNA

Sep 2021$3.0B

Dec 2021$3.1B

Mar 2022$2.9B

Jun 2022$2.9B

Sep 2022$3.0B

Dec 2022$3.1B

Mar 2023$3.2B

Jun 2023$3.3B

Sep 2023$3.3B

Dec 2023$3.5B

Mar 2024$3.4B

Jun 2024$3.5B

Sep 2024$3.6B

Dec 2024$3.7B

Mar 2025$3.6B

Jun 2025$3.7B

Sep 2025$3.8B

Dec 2025$3.8B

Mar 2026$3.7B

Jun 2026—

Loews Corporation · L

Sep 2021$3.4B

Dec 2021$3.7B

Mar 2022$3.4B

Jun 2022$3.4B

Sep 2022$3.5B

Dec 2022$3.8B

Mar 2023$3.8B

Jun 2023$3.9B

Sep 2023$3.9B

Dec 2023$4.3B

Mar 2024$4.2B

Jun 2024$4.3B

Sep 2024$4.5B

Dec 2024$4.5B

Mar 2025$4.5B

Jun 2025$4.6B

Sep 2025$4.7B

Dec 2025$4.7B

Mar 2026$4.6B

Jun 2026—

Markel Group Inc. · MKL

Sep 2021$2.7B

Dec 2021$3.8B

Mar 2022$2.6B

Jun 2022$1.8B

Sep 2022$3.1B

Dec 2022$4.2B

Mar 2023$3.6B

Jun 2023$4.1B

Sep 2023$3.4B

Dec 2023$4.6B

Mar 2024$4.5B

Jun 2024$3.7B

Sep 2024$3.7B

Dec 2024$3.7B

Mar 2025$3.5B

Jun 2025$4.6B

Sep 2025$3.9B

Dec 2025$4.0B

Mar 2026$3.6B

Jun 2026—

Old Republic International Corporation · ORI

Sep 2021$2.0B

Dec 2021$2.7B

Mar 2022$2.2B

Jun 2022$1.8B

Sep 2022$1.7B

Dec 2022$2.3B

Mar 2023$1.8B

Jun 2023$1.8B

Sep 2023$1.8B

Dec 2023$1.9B

Mar 2024$2.0B

Jun 2024$1.9B

Sep 2024$2.3B

Dec 2024$2.0B

Mar 2025$2.1B

Jun 2025$2.2B

Sep 2025$2.4B

Dec 2025$2.4B

Mar 2026$2.4B

Jun 2026—

The Allstate Corporation · ALL

Sep 2021$12.5B

Dec 2021$13.0B

Mar 2022$12.3B

Jun 2022$12.2B

Sep 2022$13.2B

Dec 2022$13.6B

Mar 2023$13.8B

Jun 2023$14.0B

Sep 2023$14.5B

Dec 2023$14.8B

Mar 2024$15.3B

Jun 2024$15.7B

Sep 2024$16.6B

Dec 2024$16.5B

Mar 2025$16.5B

Jun 2025$16.6B

Sep 2025$17.3B

Dec 2025$17.3B

Mar 2026$16.9B

Jun 2026—

The Progressive Corporation · PGR

Sep 2021$11.9B

Dec 2021$12.5B

Mar 2022$11.8B

Jun 2022$11.5B

Sep 2022$12.8B

Dec 2022$13.5B

Mar 2023$14.3B

Jun 2023$15.4B

Sep 2023$15.6B

Dec 2023$16.9B

Mar 2024$17.2B

Jun 2024$18.1B

Sep 2024$19.7B

Dec 2024$20.3B

Mar 2025$20.4B

Jun 2025$22.0B

Sep 2025$22.5B

Dec 2025$22.7B

Mar 2026$22.2B

Jun 2026—

The Travelers Companies, Inc. · TRV

Sep 2021$8.8B

Dec 2021$9.0B

Mar 2022$8.8B

Jun 2022$9.1B

Sep 2022$9.3B

Dec 2022$9.6B

Mar 2023$9.7B

Jun 2023$10.1B

Sep 2023$10.6B

Dec 2023$10.9B

Mar 2024$11.2B

Jun 2024$11.3B

Sep 2024$11.9B

Dec 2024$12.0B

Mar 2025$11.8B

Jun 2025$12.1B

Sep 2025$12.5B

Dec 2025$12.4B

Mar 2026$11.9B

Jun 2026—

W. R. Berkley Corporation · WRB

Sep 2021$2.4B

Dec 2021$2.6B

Mar 2022$2.9B

Jun 2022$2.5B

Sep 2022$2.7B

Dec 2022$3.0B

Mar 2023$2.9B

Jun 2023$3.0B

Sep 2023$3.0B

Dec 2023$3.2B

Mar 2024$3.3B

Jun 2024$3.3B

Sep 2024$3.4B

Dec 2024$3.7B

Mar 2025$3.5B

Jun 2025$3.7B

Sep 2025$3.8B

Dec 2025$3.7B

Mar 2026$3.7B

Jun 2026—

Income growth · reported quarter history

Showing the 12 largest of 30 companies with a series here. The remaining 18 are complete in the plain-text rendition and the trace payload — nothing is dropped from the data, only from this grid.

American Financial Group, Inc. · AFG

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 20220.5%

Sep 202213%

Dec 20229.7%

Mar 20239.6%

Jun 202320%

Sep 20239.1%

Dec 20238.0%

Mar 20249.5%

Jun 20243.3%

Sep 20249.5%

Dec 20243.2%

Mar 2025-2.6%

Jun 20251.3%

Sep 2025-1.6%

Dec 2025-4.0%

Mar 2026-0.1%

Jun 2026—

Assurant, Inc. · AIZ

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-1.3%

Sep 2022-3.4%

Dec 20223.0%

Mar 20236.4%

Jun 20238.8%

Sep 20238.9%

Dec 202312%

Mar 20249.0%

Jun 20247.1%

Sep 20247.0%

Dec 20244.1%

Mar 20256.7%

Jun 20258.0%

Sep 20258.9%

Dec 20257.9%

Mar 202611%

Jun 2026—

Chubb Limited · CB

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 20222.5%

Sep 202212%

Dec 20224.9%

Mar 202315%

Jun 202320%

Sep 202314%

Dec 202317%

Mar 202417%

Jun 202417%

Sep 20247.2%

Dec 20249.8%

Mar 20253.6%

Jun 202512%

Sep 20259.0%

Dec 20256.9%

Mar 202611%

Jun 2026—

Cincinnati Financial Corporation · CINF

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-64%

Sep 2022-21%

Dec 2022-6.2%

Mar 202384%

Jun 2023218%

Sep 202328%

Dec 20237.7%

Mar 202431%

Jun 2024-2.3%

Sep 202483%

Dec 2024-24%

Mar 2025-13%

Jun 202528%

Sep 202512%

Dec 202522%

Mar 202612%

Jun 2026—

CNA Financial Corporation · CNA

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-3.4%

Sep 2022-0.1%

Dec 20221.9%

Mar 20239.3%

Jun 202313%

Sep 202313%

Dec 202313%

Mar 20249.3%

Jun 20246.5%

Sep 20248.5%

Dec 20245.2%

Mar 20255.3%

Jun 20255.6%

Sep 20255.5%

Dec 20253.8%

Mar 20261.4%

Jun 2026—

Loews Corporation · L

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-15%

Sep 20222.7%

Dec 20223.6%

Mar 202311%

Jun 202316%

Sep 202313%

Dec 202312%

Mar 202412%

Jun 20248.5%

Sep 202414%

Dec 20246.8%

Mar 20256.2%

Jun 20256.8%

Sep 20254.6%

Dec 20254.1%

Mar 20261.4%

Jun 2026—

Markel Group Inc. · MKL

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-49%

Sep 202214%

Dec 202212%

Mar 202340%

Jun 2023131%

Sep 202310%

Dec 202310%

Mar 202423%

Jun 2024-11%

Sep 20249.5%

Dec 2024-20%

Mar 2025-21%

Jun 202524%

Sep 20256.5%

Dec 20257.6%

Mar 20260.1%

Jun 2026—

Old Republic International Corporation · ORI

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-20%

Sep 2022-14%

Dec 2022-14%

Mar 2023-20%

Jun 2023-0.7%

Sep 20232.3%

Dec 2023-17%

Mar 202415%

Jun 20244.1%

Sep 202433%

Dec 20243.1%

Mar 20254.9%

Jun 202518%

Sep 20253.5%

Dec 202519%

Mar 202613%

Jun 2026—

The Allstate Corporation · ALL

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-3.4%

Sep 20225.8%

Dec 20224.8%

Mar 202312%

Jun 202314%

Sep 20239.8%

Dec 20238.7%

Mar 202411%

Jun 202412%

Sep 202415%

Dec 202411%

Mar 20257.8%

Jun 20255.9%

Sep 20253.8%

Dec 20255.1%

Mar 20263.0%

Jun 2026—

The Progressive Corporation · PGR

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-3.3%

Sep 20227.8%

Dec 20227.8%

Mar 202321%

Jun 202333%

Sep 202322%

Dec 202325%

Mar 202421%

Jun 202418%

Sep 202427%

Dec 202420%

Mar 202518%

Jun 202521%

Sep 202514%

Dec 202512%

Mar 20268.7%

Jun 2026—

The Travelers Companies, Inc. · TRV

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 20225.2%

Sep 20225.7%

Dec 20226.9%

Mar 202310%

Jun 202311%

Sep 202314%

Dec 202313%

Mar 202416%

Jun 202412%

Sep 202412%

Dec 20249.9%

Mar 20255.2%

Jun 20257.4%

Sep 20254.8%

Dec 20253.5%

Mar 20261.0%

Jun 2026—

W. R. Berkley Corporation · WRB

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 20229.5%

Sep 202212%

Dec 202217%

Mar 2023-0.7%

Jun 202319%

Sep 202311%

Dec 20236.9%

Mar 202413%

Jun 202411%

Sep 202412%

Dec 202414%

Mar 20258.9%

Jun 202511%

Sep 202511%

Dec 20251.4%

Mar 20264.0%

Jun 2026—

02 · compare level, then change

Profit Scale & Acceleration

The Allstate Corporation has the highest Net profit among the 30 Insurance - Property & Casualty companies compared here, at $12,128 million. Cincinnati Financial Corporation is next at $2,757 million. The same company also holds the highest Profit growth, at the 100% top of the scoring scale. 21 of 30 companies report a comparable reading, the latest through Mar 2026.

What the numbers say: The Allstate Corporation leads with $12,128 million of TTM profit, 339.9% above Cincinnati Financial Corporation. The Allstate Corporation shows ≥100% on the scoring scale (203.4% uncapped) growth from a $12,128 million profit base. Compare the size of the base and persistence before ranking acceleration above profit scale.

LeaderThe Allstate Corporation · $12,128 million

Gap339.9% versus #2 · Cincinnati Financial Corporation

Persistence5/8 recent comparable periods

Coverage21/30 companies · 564 observations

Investor read: The Allstate Corporation sets the level benchmark; use the change leader as an inflection watch only after another comparable report confirms it.

This conclusion weakens if: The next two comparable reports reverse the current profit growth signal.

Net profit is ranked only where the comparison base is economically meaningful. Loss-to-profit flips are shown but do not win the growth table.

Net profitlargest

1The Allstate Corporation ALL$12.1B

2Cincinnati Financial Corporation CINF$2.8B

3Markel Group Inc. MKL$1.8B

4Loews Corporation L$1.7B

5CNA Financial Corporation CNA$1.2B

Profit growthfastest growers

1The Allstate Corporation ALL100%

2HCI Group, Inc. HCI100%

3Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. SLDE100%

4White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. WTM100%

5United Fire Group, Inc. UFCS97%

Net profit · company comparison

21/30 level · 17/30 change

Solid lines show level; dotted lines show change when “Both” is selected. Missing reports break the line rather than being invented.

All-company data · latest reported quarter

Each figure is the company’s latest single reported quarter. The rankings above use trailing-twelve-month or current-market values, so a company can legitimately show a different number in each.

Company	Net profit	Profit growth	Reported
The Progressive Corporation PGR	$2.8B	9.8%	Jun 2026
The Allstate Corporation ALL	$2.5B	312%	Mar 2026
Chubb Limited CB	$2.3B	75%	Jun 2026
The Travelers Companies, Inc. TRV	$1.7B	333%	Jun 2026
W. R. Berkley Corporation WRB	$516M	24%	Jun 2026
Loews Corporation L	$354M	-9.7%	Mar 2026
Old Republic International Corporation ORI	$330M	34%	Jun 2026
Cincinnati Financial Corporation CINF	$274M	67%	Mar 2026
Assurant, Inc. AIZ	$274M	86%	Mar 2026
CNA Financial Corporation CNA	$211M	-23%	Mar 2026
American Financial Group, Inc. AFG	$191M	24%	Mar 2026
Mercury General Corporation MCY	$190M	101%	Mar 2026
The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. THG	$187M	46%	Mar 2026
Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. SLDE	$140M	51%	Mar 2026
Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. KNSL	$113M	27%	Jun 2026
Selective Insurance Group, Inc. SIGI	$98M	-11%	Jun 2026
HCI Group, Inc. HCI	$85M	15%	Mar 2026
RLI Corp. RLI	$55M	-13%	Jun 2026
Skyward Specialty Insurance Group, Inc. SKWD	$50M	19%	Mar 2026
Palomar Holdings, Inc. PLMR	$43M	0.0%	Mar 2026
Horace Mann Educators Corporation HMN	$41M	7.9%	Mar 2026
United Fire Group, Inc. UFCS	$30M	67%	Mar 2026
Stewart Information Services Corporation STC	$19M	280%	Jun 2026
Porch Group, Inc. PRCH	$2M	-50%	Mar 2026
Kemper Corporation KMPR	$-4M	-104%	Mar 2026
Hagerty, Inc. HGTY	$-13M	-148%	Mar 2026
Safety Insurance Group, Inc. SAFT	$-14M	-164%	Mar 2026
White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. WTM	$-26M	-141%	Mar 2026
Lemonade, Inc. LMND	$-36M	—	Mar 2026
Markel Group Inc. MKL	$-204M	-258%	Mar 2026

Full 20-quarter history · every available company

Net profit · reported quarter history

Showing the 12 largest of 30 companies with a series here. The remaining 18 are complete in the plain-text rendition and the trace payload — nothing is dropped from the data, only from this grid.

American Financial Group, Inc. · AFG

Sep 2021$219M

Dec 2021$355M

Mar 2022$290M

Jun 2022$167M

Sep 2022$165M

Dec 2022$276M

Mar 2023$212M

Jun 2023$200M

Sep 2023$177M

Dec 2023$263M

Mar 2024$242M

Jun 2024$209M

Sep 2024$181M

Dec 2024$255M

Mar 2025$154M

Jun 2025$174M

Sep 2025$215M

Dec 2025$299M

Mar 2026$191M

Jun 2026—

Assurant, Inc. · AIZ

Sep 2021$880M

Dec 2021$121M

Mar 2022$149M

Jun 2022$52M

Sep 2022$7M

Dec 2022$68M

Mar 2023$114M

Jun 2023$156M

Sep 2023$190M

Dec 2023$183M

Mar 2024$236M

Jun 2024$189M

Sep 2024$134M

Dec 2024$201M

Mar 2025$147M

Jun 2025$235M

Sep 2025$266M

Dec 2025$225M

Mar 2026$274M

Jun 2026—

Chubb Limited · CB

Sep 2021$1.8B

Dec 2021$2.1B

Mar 2022$2.0B

Jun 2022$1.2B

Sep 2022$792M

Dec 2022$1.3B

Mar 2023$1.9B

Jun 2023$1.8B

Sep 2023$2.0B

Dec 2023$3.3B

Mar 2024$2.3B

Jun 2024$2.2B

Sep 2024$2.5B

Dec 2024$2.6B

Mar 2025$1.3B

Jun 2025$3.0B

Sep 2025$3.1B

Dec 2025$3.2B

Mar 2026$2.3B

Jun 2026—

Cincinnati Financial Corporation · CINF

Sep 2021$153M

Dec 2021$1.5B

Mar 2022$-266M

Jun 2022$-818M

Sep 2022$-416M

Dec 2022$1.0B

Mar 2023$225M

Jun 2023$534M

Sep 2023$-99M

Dec 2023$1.2B

Mar 2024$755M

Jun 2024$312M

Sep 2024$820M

Dec 2024$405M

Mar 2025$-90M

Jun 2025$685M

Sep 2025$1.1B

Dec 2025$676M

Mar 2026$274M

Jun 2026—

CNA Financial Corporation · CNA

Sep 2021$256M

Dec 2021$248M

Mar 2022$295M

Jun 2022$190M

Sep 2022$-42M

Dec 2022$239M

Mar 2023$297M

Jun 2023$283M

Sep 2023$258M

Dec 2023$367M

Mar 2024$338M

Jun 2024$317M

Sep 2024$283M

Dec 2024$21M

Mar 2025$274M

Jun 2025$299M

Sep 2025$403M

Dec 2025$302M

Mar 2026$211M

Jun 2026—

Loews Corporation · L

Sep 2021$246M

Dec 2021$353M

Mar 2022$352M

Jun 2022$187M

Sep 2022$-27M

Dec 2022$379M

Mar 2023$404M

Jun 2023$388M

Sep 2023$276M

Dec 2023$477M

Mar 2024$485M

Jun 2024$395M

Sep 2024$425M

Dec 2024$189M

Mar 2025$392M

Jun 2025$416M

Sep 2025$536M

Dec 2025$428M

Mar 2026$354M

Jun 2026—

Markel Group Inc. · MKL

Sep 2021$190M

Dec 2021$873M

Mar 2022$-49M

Jun 2022$-883M

Sep 2022$117M

Dec 2022$712M

Mar 2023$538M

Jun 2023$716M

Sep 2023$53M

Dec 2023$794M

Mar 2024$1.0B

Jun 2024$290M

Sep 2024$947M

Dec 2024$561M

Mar 2025$129M

Jun 2025$677M

Sep 2025$764M

Dec 2025$582M

Mar 2026$-204M

Jun 2026—

Old Republic International Corporation · ORI

Sep 2021$89M

Dec 2021$627M

Mar 2022$306M

Jun 2022$-40M

Sep 2022$-92M

Dec 2022$512M

Mar 2023$200M

Jun 2023$156M

Sep 2023$53M

Dec 2023$191M

Mar 2024$317M

Jun 2024$92M

Sep 2024$339M

Dec 2024$105M

Mar 2025$246M

Jun 2025$208M

Sep 2025$280M

Dec 2025$207M

Mar 2026$330M

Jun 2026—

The Allstate Corporation · ALL

Sep 2021$531M

Dec 2021$806M

Mar 2022$650M

Jun 2022$-1.0B

Sep 2022$-674M

Dec 2022$-296M

Mar 2023$-321M

Jun 2023$-1.4B

Sep 2023$-4M

Dec 2023$1.5B

Mar 2024$1.2B

Jun 2024$347M

Sep 2024$1.2B

Dec 2024$1.9B

Mar 2025$596M

Jun 2025$2.1B

Sep 2025$3.7B

Dec 2025$3.8B

Mar 2026$2.5B

Jun 2026—

The Progressive Corporation · PGR

Sep 2021$119M

Dec 2021$962M

Mar 2022$314M

Jun 2022$-543M

Sep 2022$124M

Dec 2022$827M

Mar 2023$448M

Jun 2023$345M

Sep 2023$1.1B

Dec 2023$2.0B

Mar 2024$2.3B

Jun 2024$1.5B

Sep 2024$2.3B

Dec 2024$2.4B

Mar 2025$2.6B

Jun 2025$3.2B

Sep 2025$2.6B

Dec 2025$3.0B

Mar 2026$2.8B

Jun 2026—

The Travelers Companies, Inc. · TRV

Sep 2021$662M

Dec 2021$1.3B

Mar 2022$1.0B

Jun 2022$551M

Sep 2022$454M

Dec 2022$819M

Mar 2023$975M

Jun 2023$-14M

Sep 2023$404M

Dec 2023$1.6B

Mar 2024$1.1B

Jun 2024$534M

Sep 2024$1.3B

Dec 2024$2.1B

Mar 2025$395M

Jun 2025$1.5B

Sep 2025$1.9B

Dec 2025$2.5B

Mar 2026$1.7B

Jun 2026—

W. R. Berkley Corporation · WRB

Sep 2021$267M

Dec 2021$294M

Mar 2022$593M

Jun 2022$179M

Sep 2022$230M

Dec 2022$382M

Mar 2023$296M

Jun 2023$356M

Sep 2023$333M

Dec 2023$399M

Mar 2024$442M

Jun 2024$372M

Sep 2024$365M

Dec 2024$575M

Mar 2025$417M

Jun 2025$401M

Sep 2025$512M

Dec 2025$455M

Mar 2026$516M

Jun 2026—

Profit growth · reported quarter history

Showing the 12 largest of 29 companies with a series here. The remaining 17 are complete in the plain-text rendition and the trace payload — nothing is dropped from the data, only from this grid.

American Financial Group, Inc. · AFG

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-30%

Sep 2022-25%

Dec 2022-22%

Mar 2023-27%

Jun 202320%

Sep 20237.3%

Dec 2023-4.7%

Mar 202414%

Jun 20244.5%

Sep 20242.3%

Dec 2024-3.0%

Mar 2025-36%

Jun 2025-17%

Sep 202519%

Dec 202517%

Mar 202624%

Jun 2026—

Assurant, Inc. · AIZ

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-75%

Sep 2022-99%

Dec 2022-44%

Mar 2023-23%

Jun 2023200%

Sep 20232,614%

Dec 2023169%

Mar 2024107%

Jun 202421%

Sep 2024-29%

Dec 20249.8%

Mar 2025-38%

Jun 202524%

Sep 202599%

Dec 202512%

Mar 202686%

Jun 2026—

Chubb Limited · CB

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-47%

Sep 2022-57%

Dec 2022-39%

Mar 2023-3.1%

Jun 202351%

Sep 2023158%

Dec 2023151%

Mar 202421%

Jun 202424%

Sep 202422%

Dec 2024-20%

Mar 2025-41%

Jun 202535%

Sep 202525%

Dec 202520%

Mar 202675%

Jun 2026—

Cincinnati Financial Corporation · CINF

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-216%

Sep 2022-372%

Dec 2022-32%

Mar 2023—

Jun 2023—

Sep 2023—

Dec 202317%

Mar 2024236%

Jun 2024-42%

Sep 2024—

Dec 2024-66%

Mar 2025-112%

Jun 2025120%

Sep 202537%

Dec 202567%

Mar 2026—

Jun 2026—

CNA Financial Corporation · CNA

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-48%

Sep 2022-116%

Dec 2022-3.6%

Mar 20230.7%

Jun 202349%

Sep 2023—

Dec 202354%

Mar 202414%

Jun 202412%

Sep 20249.7%

Dec 2024-94%

Mar 2025-19%

Jun 2025-5.7%

Sep 202542%

Dec 20251,338%

Mar 2026-23%

Jun 2026—

Loews Corporation · L

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-76%

Sep 2022-111%

Dec 20227.4%

Mar 202315%

Jun 2023107%

Sep 2023—

Dec 202326%

Mar 202420%

Jun 20241.8%

Sep 202454%

Dec 2024-60%

Mar 2025-19%

Jun 20255.3%

Sep 202526%

Dec 2025126%

Mar 2026-9.7%

Jun 2026—

Markel Group Inc. · MKL

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-210%

Sep 2022-38%

Dec 2022-18%

Mar 2023—

Jun 2023—

Sep 2023-55%

Dec 202312%

Mar 202495%

Jun 2024-60%

Sep 20241,687%

Dec 2024-29%

Mar 2025-88%

Jun 2025133%

Sep 2025-19%

Dec 20253.7%

Mar 2026-258%

Jun 2026—

Old Republic International Corporation · ORI

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-113%

Sep 2022-203%

Dec 2022-18%

Mar 2023-35%

Jun 2023—

Sep 2023—

Dec 2023-63%

Mar 202459%

Jun 2024-41%

Sep 2024540%

Dec 2024-45%

Mar 2025-22%

Jun 2025126%

Sep 2025-17%

Dec 202597%

Mar 202634%

Jun 2026—

The Allstate Corporation · ALL

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-163%

Sep 2022-227%

Dec 2022-137%

Mar 2023-149%

Jun 2023—

Sep 2023—

Dec 2023—

Mar 2024—

Jun 2024—

Sep 2024—

Dec 202427%

Mar 2025-50%

Jun 2025505%

Sep 2025222%

Dec 2025102%

Mar 2026312%

Jun 2026—

The Progressive Corporation · PGR

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-169%

Sep 20224.2%

Dec 2022-14%

Mar 202343%

Jun 2023—

Sep 2023804%

Dec 2023140%

Mar 2024420%

Jun 2024323%

Sep 2024108%

Dec 202419%

Mar 202510%

Jun 2025118%

Sep 202512%

Dec 202525%

Mar 20269.8%

Jun 2026—

The Travelers Companies, Inc. · TRV

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-41%

Sep 2022-31%

Dec 2022-39%

Mar 2023-4.2%

Jun 2023-103%

Sep 2023-11%

Dec 202399%

Mar 202415%

Jun 2024—

Sep 2024212%

Dec 202428%

Mar 2025-65%

Jun 2025183%

Sep 202550%

Dec 202520%

Mar 2026333%

Jun 2026—

W. R. Berkley Corporation · WRB

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022-25%

Sep 2022-14%

Dec 202230%

Mar 2023-50%

Jun 202399%

Sep 202345%

Dec 20234.5%

Mar 202449%

Jun 20244.5%

Sep 20249.6%

Dec 202444%

Mar 2025-5.7%

Jun 20257.8%

Sep 202540%

Dec 2025-21%

Mar 202624%

Jun 2026—

03 · compare level, then change

Funding Base & Its Composition

No company in this Insurance - Property & Casualty comparison has a funding base figure that passes this section's guard, so the Deposits rank is empty. On Borrowings, Loews Corporation is highest at $8,934 million, across 10 of 30 companies with a usable reading.

What the numbers say: There is not enough comparable evidence to name a reliable deposits leader.

LeaderNo comparable leader

GapNot enough peers

PersistenceNot enough history

Coverage0/30 companies · 0 observations

Investor read: The current leader sets the level benchmark; use the change leader as an inflection watch only after another comparable report confirms it.

This conclusion weakens if: The next two comparable reports reverse the current borrowings signal.

For banks, debt is operating funding rather than industrial leverage. Deposits and borrowings are therefore shown as funding-base levels; asset quality, funding cost and liquidity determine whether that funding is attractive.

Depositslargest deposit bases

—Not enough comparable data—

Borrowingslargest borrowings

1Loews Corporation L$8.9B

2Cincinnati Financial Corporation CINF$859M

3Porch Group, Inc. PRCH$391M

4Palomar Holdings, Inc. PLMR$297M

5Stewart Information Services Corporation STC$124M

Funding base · company comparison

0/30 level · 10/30 change

Solid lines show level; dotted lines show change when “Both” is selected. Missing reports break the line rather than being invented.

All-company data · latest reported quarter

Each figure is the company’s latest single reported quarter. The rankings above use trailing-twelve-month or current-market values, so a company can legitimately show a different number in each.

Company	Deposits	Borrowings	Reported
Cincinnati Financial Corporation CINF	—	$859M	Mar 2026
Loews Corporation L	—	$8.9B	Mar 2026
Mercury General Corporation MCY	—	$13M	Mar 2026
Hagerty, Inc. HGTY	—	$0M	Mar 2026
Palomar Holdings, Inc. PLMR	—	$297M	Mar 2026
Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. SLDE	—	$9M	Mar 2026
HCI Group, Inc. HCI	—	$32M	Mar 2026
Stewart Information Services Corporation STC	—	$124M	Jun 2026
Safety Insurance Group, Inc. SAFT	—	$11M	Mar 2026
Porch Group, Inc. PRCH	—	$391M	Mar 2026

Full 20-quarter history · every available company

No consistent historical series is available for deposits.

Borrowings · reported quarter history

Cincinnati Financial Corporation · CINF

Sep 2021$845M

Dec 2021$843M

Mar 2022$841M

Jun 2022$841M

Sep 2022$843M

Dec 2022$841M

Mar 2023$845M

Jun 2023$842M

Sep 2023$844M

Dec 2023$849M

Mar 2024$848M

Jun 2024$849M

Sep 2024$849M

Dec 2024$850M

Mar 2025$853M

Jun 2025$859M

Sep 2025$858M

Dec 2025$861M

Mar 2026$859M

Jun 2026—

Hagerty, Inc. · HGTY

Sep 2021$0M

Dec 2021$0M

Mar 2022$0M

Jun 2022$0M

Sep 2022$0M

Dec 2022$81M

Mar 2023$79M

Jun 2023$77M

Sep 2023$52M

Dec 2023$50M

Mar 2024$49M

Jun 2024$47M

Sep 2024$45M

Dec 2024$0M

Mar 2025$42M

Jun 2025$41M

Sep 2025$41M

Dec 2025$0M

Mar 2026$0M

Jun 2026—

HCI Group, Inc. · HCI

Sep 2021$78M

Dec 2021$46M

Mar 2022$45M

Jun 2022$212M

Sep 2022$212M

Dec 2022$212M

Mar 2023$196M

Jun 2023$208M

Sep 2023$208M

Dec 2023$208M

Mar 2024$185M

Jun 2024$185M

Sep 2024$185M

Dec 2024$185M

Mar 2025$185M

Jun 2025$16M

Sep 2025$32M

Dec 2025$32M

Mar 2026$32M

Jun 2026—

Loews Corporation · L

Sep 2021$9.1B

Dec 2021$9.1B

Mar 2022$9.3B

Jun 2022$9.3B

Sep 2022$9.3B

Dec 2022$9.0B

Mar 2023$9.1B

Jun 2023$9.1B

Sep 2023$9.2B

Dec 2023$1.1B

Mar 2024$10.1B

Jun 2024$8.6B

Sep 2024$9.5B

Dec 2024$8.9B

Mar 2025$8.9B

Jun 2025$8.9B

Sep 2025$9.4B

Dec 2025$9.5B

Mar 2026$8.9B

Jun 2026—

Mercury General Corporation · MCY

Sep 2021$37M

Dec 2021$35M

Mar 2022$32M

Jun 2022$166M

Sep 2022$26M

Dec 2022$22M

Mar 2023$19M

Jun 2023$20M

Sep 2023$19M

Dec 2023$14M

Mar 2024$14M

Jun 2024$14M

Sep 2024$14M

Dec 2024$14M

Mar 2025$18M

Jun 2025$16M

Sep 2025$14M

Dec 2025$12M

Mar 2026$13M

Jun 2026—

Palomar Holdings, Inc. · PLMR

Sep 2021$0M

Dec 2021$0M

Mar 2022$15M

Jun 2022$23M

Sep 2022$26M

Dec 2022$36M

Mar 2023$71M

Jun 2023$71M

Sep 2023$53M

Dec 2023$53M

Mar 2024$43M

Jun 2024$0M

Sep 2024$0M

Dec 2024$0M

Mar 2025$0M

Jun 2025$0M

Sep 2025$0M

Dec 2025$0M

Mar 2026$297M

Jun 2026—

Porch Group, Inc. · PRCH

Sep 2021$418M

Dec 2021$417M

Mar 2022$417M

Jun 2022$420M

Sep 2022$434M

Dec 2022$442M

Mar 2023$438M

Jun 2023$435M

Sep 2023$435M

Dec 2023$436M

Mar 2024$432M

Jun 2024$437M

Sep 2024$399M

Dec 2024$404M

Mar 2025$409M

Jun 2025$394M

Sep 2025$387M

Dec 2025$385M

Mar 2026$391M

Jun 2026—

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. · SAFT

Sep 2021$27M

Dec 2021$27M

Mar 2022$27M

Jun 2022$25M

Sep 2022$24M

Dec 2022$23M

Mar 2023$22M

Jun 2023$22M

Sep 2023$21M

Dec 2023$20M

Mar 2024$19M

Jun 2024$18M

Sep 2024$17M

Dec 2024$16M

Mar 2025$15M

Jun 2025$14M

Sep 2025$13M

Dec 2025$12M

Mar 2026$11M

Jun 2026—

Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. · SLDE

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022$8M

Dec 2022$8M

Mar 2023—

Jun 2023—

Sep 2023$7M

Dec 2023$7M

Mar 2024$7M

Jun 2024$7M

Sep 2024$7M

Dec 2024$9M

Mar 2025$9M

Jun 2025$8M

Sep 2025$10M

Dec 2025$10M

Mar 2026$9M

Jun 2026—

Stewart Information Services Corporation · STC

Sep 2021$129M

Dec 2021$149M

Mar 2022$155M

Jun 2022$150M

Sep 2022$146M

Dec 2022$148M

Mar 2023$148M

Jun 2023$147M

Sep 2023$142M

Dec 2023$136M

Mar 2024$133M

Jun 2024$127M

Sep 2024$123M

Dec 2024$119M

Mar 2025$114M

Jun 2025$130M

Sep 2025$125M

Dec 2025$122M

Mar 2026$124M

Jun 2026$124M

04 · compare level, then change

Return On Assets

Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. has the highest ROA among the 30 Insurance - Property & Casualty companies compared here, at 5.8%. Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. is next at 3%. Mercury General Corporation has the highest ROA change at +3.4 percentage points, so level and change sit with different companies. Its ROA series carries 13 reported observations across the 20-quarter window.

What the numbers say: Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. leads roa at 5.8%; Mercury General Corporation leads roa change at +3.4 percentage points.

LeaderSlide Insurance Holdings, Inc. · 5.8%

Gap93.3% versus #2 · Kinsale Capital Group, Inc.

Persistence5/8 recent comparable periods

Coverage28/30 companies · 535 observations

Investor read: Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. sets the level benchmark; use the change leader as an inflection watch only after another comparable report confirms it.

This conclusion weakens if: The next two comparable reports reverse the current roa change signal.

ROA is the cleanest first comparison for lenders because the balance sheet is the operating asset.

ROAhighest

1Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. SLDE5.8%

2Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. KNSL3.0%

3The Progressive Corporation PGR2.8%

4RLI Corp. RLI2.7%

5Porch Group, Inc. PRCH2.2%

ROA changefastest improvers

1Mercury General Corporation MCY+3.4 pp

2Porch Group, Inc. PRCH+2.4 pp

3Lemonade, Inc. LMND+1.7 pp

4The Allstate Corporation ALL+1.5 pp

5W. R. Berkley Corporation WRB+1.2 pp

Return on assets · company comparison

28/30 level · 28/30 change

Solid lines show level; dotted lines show change when “Both” is selected. Missing reports break the line rather than being invented.

All-company data · latest reported quarter

Each figure is the company’s latest single reported quarter. The rankings above use trailing-twelve-month or current-market values, so a company can legitimately show a different number in each.

Company	ROA	ROA change	Reported
Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. SLDE	5.8%	+0.5 pp	Mar 2026
Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. KNSL	3.0%	+0.3 pp	Jun 2026
The Progressive Corporation PGR	2.8%	−0.2 pp	Jun 2026
RLI Corp. RLI	2.7%	+0.6 pp	Jun 2026
W. R. Berkley Corporation WRB	2.2%	+1.2 pp	Jun 2026
Porch Group, Inc. PRCH	2.2%	+2.4 pp	Mar 2026
The Allstate Corporation ALL	2.1%	+1.5 pp	Mar 2026
Mercury General Corporation MCY	2.1%	+3.4 pp	Mar 2026
The Travelers Companies, Inc. TRV	1.6%	+0.4 pp	Jun 2026
Stewart Information Services Corporation STC	1.6%	+0.1 pp	Jun 2026
The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. THG	1.2%	+0.3 pp	Mar 2026
Chubb Limited CB	1.1%	−0.4 pp	Jun 2026
Old Republic International Corporation ORI	1.1%	+0.4 pp	Jun 2026
Skyward Specialty Insurance Group, Inc. SKWD	1.1%	−0.1 pp	Mar 2026
Selective Insurance Group, Inc. SIGI	0.9%	+0.2 pp	Jun 2026
United Fire Group, Inc. UFCS	0.9%	+0.3 pp	Mar 2026
Assurant, Inc. AIZ	0.8%	+0.3 pp	Mar 2026
Cincinnati Financial Corporation CINF	0.7%	+0.9 pp	Mar 2026
American Financial Group, Inc. AFG	0.6%	+0.1 pp	Mar 2026
Loews Corporation L	0.5%	−0.1 pp	Mar 2026
CNA Financial Corporation CNA	0.3%	−0.2 pp	Mar 2026
Horace Mann Educators Corporation HMN	0.3%	0.0 pp	Mar 2026
White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. WTM	0.0%	−1.0 pp	Mar 2026
Kemper Corporation KMPR	0.0%	−0.8 pp	Mar 2026
Markel Group Inc. MKL	-0.3%	−0.7 pp	Mar 2026
Hagerty, Inc. HGTY	-0.6%	−2.3 pp	Mar 2026
Safety Insurance Group, Inc. SAFT	-0.6%	−1.6 pp	Mar 2026
Lemonade, Inc. LMND	-1.9%	+1.7 pp	Mar 2026

Full 20-quarter history · every available company

ROA · reported quarter history

Showing the 12 largest of 28 companies with a series here. The remaining 16 are complete in the plain-text rendition and the trace payload — nothing is dropped from the data, only from this grid.

American Financial Group, Inc. · AFG

Sep 20210.4%

Dec 20210.7%

Mar 20220.6%

Jun 20220.6%

Sep 20220.6%

Dec 20221.0%

Mar 20230.7%

Jun 20230.7%

Sep 20230.6%

Dec 20230.9%

Mar 20240.8%

Jun 20240.7%

Sep 20240.6%

Dec 20240.8%

Mar 20250.5%

Jun 20250.6%

Sep 20250.6%

Dec 20250.9%

Mar 20260.6%

Jun 2026—

Assurant, Inc. · AIZ

Sep 20210.5%

Dec 20210.4%

Mar 20220.4%

Jun 20220.2%

Sep 20220.1%

Dec 20220.3%

Mar 20230.4%

Jun 20230.5%

Sep 20230.6%

Dec 20230.6%

Mar 20240.8%

Jun 20240.6%

Sep 20240.5%

Dec 20240.6%

Mar 20250.5%

Jun 20250.7%

Sep 20250.8%

Dec 20250.7%

Mar 20260.8%

Jun 2026—

Chubb Limited · CB

Sep 20210.7%

Dec 20211.1%

Mar 20220.9%

Jun 20220.7%

Sep 20220.5%

Dec 20221.1%

Mar 20231.2%

Jun 20230.9%

Sep 20231.0%

Dec 20232.1%

Mar 20241.0%

Jun 20241.0%

Sep 20241.4%

Dec 20241.5%

Mar 20250.6%

Jun 20251.5%

Sep 20251.7%

Dec 20251.3%

Mar 20260.9%

Jun 20261.1%

Cincinnati Financial Corporation · CINF

Sep 20210.6%

Dec 20215.1%

Mar 2022-0.9%

Jun 2022-2.7%

Sep 2022-1.4%

Dec 20223.3%

Mar 20230.8%

Jun 20231.8%

Sep 2023-0.3%

Dec 20233.8%

Mar 20242.4%

Jun 20241.0%

Sep 20242.4%

Dec 20241.2%

Mar 2025-0.2%

Jun 20251.9%

Sep 20252.9%

Dec 20251.8%

Mar 20260.7%

Jun 2026—

CNA Financial Corporation · CNA

Sep 20210.4%

Dec 20210.4%

Mar 20220.5%

Jun 20220.3%

Sep 20220.0%

Dec 20220.4%

Mar 20230.5%

Jun 20230.5%

Sep 20230.5%

Dec 20230.6%

Mar 20240.6%

Jun 20240.5%

Sep 20240.5%

Dec 20240.1%

Mar 20250.5%

Jun 20250.5%

Sep 20250.6%

Dec 20250.5%

Mar 20260.3%

Jun 2026—

Loews Corporation · L

Sep 20210.4%

Dec 20210.5%

Mar 20220.5%

Jun 20220.3%

Sep 20220.0%

Dec 20220.6%

Mar 20230.6%

Jun 20230.6%

Sep 20230.4%

Dec 20230.7%

Mar 20240.7%

Jun 20240.6%

Sep 20240.6%

Dec 20240.4%

Mar 20250.6%

Jun 20250.6%

Sep 20250.7%

Dec 20250.6%

Mar 20260.5%

Jun 2026—

Markel Group Inc. · MKL

Sep 20210.4%

Dec 20212.0%

Mar 2022-0.1%

Jun 2022-2.0%

Sep 20220.1%

Dec 20221.7%

Mar 20231.2%

Jun 20231.5%

Sep 20230.1%

Dec 20231.7%

Mar 20241.9%

Jun 20240.6%

Sep 20241.9%

Dec 20240.8%

Mar 20250.4%

Jun 20251.4%

Sep 20251.2%

Dec 20251.0%

Mar 2026-0.3%

Jun 2026—

Old Republic International Corporation · ORI

Sep 20210.4%

Dec 20212.6%

Mar 20221.3%

Jun 2022-0.2%

Sep 2022-0.4%

Dec 20222.0%

Mar 20230.8%

Jun 20230.6%

Sep 20230.2%

Dec 20230.7%

Mar 20241.2%

Jun 20240.3%

Sep 20241.2%

Dec 20240.4%

Mar 20250.9%

Jun 20250.7%

Sep 20250.9%

Dec 20250.7%

Mar 20261.1%

Jun 20261.1%

The Allstate Corporation · ALL

Sep 20210.2%

Dec 20211.1%

Mar 20220.6%

Jun 2022-0.8%

Sep 2022-0.5%

Dec 2022-0.2%

Mar 2023-0.3%

Jun 2023-1.3%

Sep 20230.0%

Dec 20231.6%

Mar 20241.2%

Jun 20240.4%

Sep 20241.2%

Dec 20241.8%

Mar 20250.6%

Jun 20251.3%

Sep 20252.8%

Dec 20253.4%

Mar 20262.1%

Jun 2026—

The Progressive Corporation · PGR

Sep 20210.2%

Dec 20211.5%

Mar 20220.5%

Jun 2022-0.7%

Sep 20220.2%

Dec 20221.2%

Mar 20230.6%

Jun 20230.5%

Sep 20231.5%

Dec 20232.5%

Mar 20242.7%

Jun 20241.7%

Sep 20242.5%

Dec 20242.5%

Mar 20252.6%

Jun 20253.0%

Sep 20252.4%

Dec 20252.6%

Mar 20262.5%

Jun 20262.8%

The Travelers Companies, Inc. · TRV

Sep 20210.6%

Dec 20211.2%

Mar 20220.9%

Jun 20220.5%

Sep 20220.5%

Dec 20220.8%

Mar 20230.9%

Jun 20230.0%

Sep 20230.4%

Dec 20231.4%

Mar 20241.0%

Jun 20240.5%

Sep 20241.0%

Dec 20241.7%

Mar 20250.4%

Jun 20251.2%

Sep 20251.4%

Dec 20251.9%

Mar 20261.3%

Jun 20261.6%

W. R. Berkley Corporation · WRB

Sep 20211.0%

Dec 20211.1%

Mar 20222.0%

Jun 20220.7%

Sep 20220.8%

Dec 20221.2%

Mar 20231.0%

Jun 20231.1%

Sep 20231.0%

Dec 20231.2%

Mar 20241.3%

Jun 20241.1%

Sep 20241.0%

Dec 20241.5%

Mar 20251.1%

Jun 20251.0%

Sep 20251.3%

Dec 20251.1%

Mar 20261.3%

Jun 20262.2%

ROA change · reported quarter history

Showing the 12 largest of 28 companies with a series here. The remaining 16 are complete in the plain-text rendition and the trace payload — nothing is dropped from the data, only from this grid.

American Financial Group, Inc. · AFG

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022+0.2 pp

Dec 2022+0.3 pp

Mar 2023+0.1 pp

Jun 2023+0.1 pp

Sep 20230.0 pp

Dec 2023−0.1 pp

Mar 2024+0.1 pp

Jun 20240.0 pp

Sep 20240.0 pp

Dec 2024−0.1 pp

Mar 2025−0.3 pp

Jun 2025−0.1 pp

Sep 20250.0 pp

Dec 2025+0.1 pp

Mar 2026+0.1 pp

Jun 2026—

Assurant, Inc. · AIZ

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−0.4 pp

Dec 2022−0.1 pp

Mar 20230.0 pp

Jun 2023+0.3 pp

Sep 2023+0.5 pp

Dec 2023+0.3 pp

Mar 2024+0.4 pp

Jun 2024+0.1 pp

Sep 2024−0.1 pp

Dec 20240.0 pp

Mar 2025−0.3 pp

Jun 2025+0.1 pp

Sep 2025+0.3 pp

Dec 2025+0.1 pp

Mar 2026+0.3 pp

Jun 2026—

Chubb Limited · CB

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−0.2 pp

Dec 20220.0 pp

Mar 2023+0.3 pp

Jun 2023+0.2 pp

Sep 2023+0.5 pp

Dec 2023+1.0 pp

Mar 2024−0.2 pp

Jun 2024+0.1 pp

Sep 2024+0.4 pp

Dec 2024−0.6 pp

Mar 2025−0.4 pp

Jun 2025+0.5 pp

Sep 2025+0.3 pp

Dec 2025−0.2 pp

Mar 2026+0.3 pp

Jun 2026−0.4 pp

Cincinnati Financial Corporation · CINF

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−2.0 pp

Dec 2022−1.8 pp

Mar 2023+1.7 pp

Jun 2023+4.5 pp

Sep 2023+1.1 pp

Dec 2023+0.5 pp

Mar 2024+1.6 pp

Jun 2024−0.8 pp

Sep 2024+2.7 pp

Dec 2024−2.6 pp

Mar 2025−2.6 pp

Jun 2025+0.9 pp

Sep 2025+0.5 pp

Dec 2025+0.6 pp

Mar 2026+0.9 pp

Jun 2026—

CNA Financial Corporation · CNA

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−0.4 pp

Dec 20220.0 pp

Mar 20230.0 pp

Jun 2023+0.2 pp

Sep 2023+0.5 pp

Dec 2023+0.2 pp

Mar 2024+0.1 pp

Jun 20240.0 pp

Sep 20240.0 pp

Dec 2024−0.5 pp

Mar 2025−0.1 pp

Jun 20250.0 pp

Sep 2025+0.1 pp

Dec 2025+0.4 pp

Mar 2026−0.2 pp

Jun 2026—

Loews Corporation · L

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−0.4 pp

Dec 2022+0.1 pp

Mar 2023+0.1 pp

Jun 2023+0.3 pp

Sep 2023+0.4 pp

Dec 2023+0.1 pp

Mar 2024+0.1 pp

Jun 20240.0 pp

Sep 2024+0.2 pp

Dec 2024−0.3 pp

Mar 2025−0.1 pp

Jun 20250.0 pp

Sep 2025+0.1 pp

Dec 2025+0.2 pp

Mar 2026−0.1 pp

Jun 2026—

Markel Group Inc. · MKL

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−0.3 pp

Dec 2022−0.3 pp

Mar 2023+1.3 pp

Jun 2023+3.5 pp

Sep 20230.0 pp

Dec 20230.0 pp

Mar 2024+0.7 pp

Jun 2024−0.9 pp

Sep 2024+1.8 pp

Dec 2024−0.9 pp

Mar 2025−1.5 pp

Jun 2025+0.8 pp

Sep 2025−0.7 pp

Dec 2025+0.2 pp

Mar 2026−0.7 pp

Jun 2026—

Old Republic International Corporation · ORI

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−0.8 pp

Dec 2022−0.6 pp

Mar 2023−0.5 pp

Jun 2023+0.8 pp

Sep 2023+0.6 pp

Dec 2023−1.3 pp

Mar 2024+0.4 pp

Jun 2024−0.3 pp

Sep 2024+1.0 pp

Dec 2024−0.3 pp

Mar 2025−0.3 pp

Jun 2025+0.4 pp

Sep 2025−0.3 pp

Dec 2025+0.3 pp

Mar 2026+0.2 pp

Jun 2026+0.4 pp

The Allstate Corporation · ALL

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−0.7 pp

Dec 2022−1.3 pp

Mar 2023−0.9 pp

Jun 2023−0.5 pp

Sep 2023+0.5 pp

Dec 2023+1.8 pp

Mar 2024+1.5 pp

Jun 2024+1.7 pp

Sep 2024+1.2 pp

Dec 2024+0.2 pp

Mar 2025−0.6 pp

Jun 2025+0.9 pp

Sep 2025+1.6 pp

Dec 2025+1.6 pp

Mar 2026+1.5 pp

Jun 2026—

The Progressive Corporation · PGR

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 20220.0 pp

Dec 2022−0.3 pp

Mar 2023+0.1 pp

Jun 2023+1.2 pp

Sep 2023+1.3 pp

Dec 2023+1.3 pp

Mar 2024+2.1 pp

Jun 2024+1.2 pp

Sep 2024+1.0 pp

Dec 20240.0 pp

Mar 2025−0.1 pp

Jun 2025+1.3 pp

Sep 2025−0.1 pp

Dec 2025+0.1 pp

Mar 2026−0.1 pp

Jun 2026−0.2 pp

The Travelers Companies, Inc. · TRV

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−0.1 pp

Dec 2022−0.4 pp

Mar 20230.0 pp

Jun 2023−0.5 pp

Sep 2023−0.1 pp

Dec 2023+0.6 pp

Mar 2024+0.1 pp

Jun 2024+0.5 pp

Sep 2024+0.6 pp

Dec 2024+0.3 pp

Mar 2025−0.6 pp

Jun 2025+0.7 pp

Sep 2025+0.4 pp

Dec 2025+0.2 pp

Mar 2026+0.9 pp

Jun 2026+0.4 pp

W. R. Berkley Corporation · WRB

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−0.2 pp

Dec 2022+0.1 pp

Mar 2023−1.0 pp

Jun 2023+0.4 pp

Sep 2023+0.2 pp

Dec 20230.0 pp

Mar 2024+0.3 pp

Jun 20240.0 pp

Sep 20240.0 pp

Dec 2024+0.3 pp

Mar 2025−0.2 pp

Jun 2025−0.1 pp

Sep 2025+0.3 pp

Dec 2025−0.4 pp

Mar 2026+0.2 pp

Jun 2026+1.2 pp

05 · compare level, then change

ROE — Leaders & Improvers

Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. has the highest ROE among the 30 Insurance - Property & Casualty companies compared here, at 17%. HCI Group, Inc. is next at 9.9%. Mercury General Corporation has the highest ROE change at +14.9 percentage points, so level and change sit with different companies. Its ROE series carries 13 reported observations across the 20-quarter window.

What the numbers say: Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. leads roe at 17%; Mercury General Corporation leads roe change at +14.9 percentage points.

LeaderSlide Insurance Holdings, Inc. · 17%

Gap71.7% versus #2 · HCI Group, Inc.

Persistence3/8 recent comparable periods

Coverage30/30 companies · 573 observations

Investor read: Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. sets the level benchmark; use the change leader as an inflection watch only after another comparable report confirms it.

This conclusion weakens if: The next two comparable reports reverse the current roe change signal.

ROE shows the return to shareholders, but should be read with asset quality and leverage.

ROEhighest

1Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. SLDE17%

2HCI Group, Inc. HCI9.9%

3The Progressive Corporation PGR9.9%

4W. R. Berkley Corporation WRB9.7%

5RLI Corp. RLI9.6%

ROE changefastest improvers

1Mercury General Corporation MCY+14.9 pp

2The Allstate Corporation ALL+6.3 pp

3W. R. Berkley Corporation WRB+5.0 pp

4Lemonade, Inc. LMND+3.5 pp

5Cincinnati Financial Corporation CINF+2.6 pp

Return on equity · company comparison

30/30 level · 30/30 change

Solid lines show level; dotted lines show change when “Both” is selected. Missing reports break the line rather than being invented.

All-company data · latest reported quarter

Each figure is the company’s latest single reported quarter. The rankings above use trailing-twelve-month or current-market values, so a company can legitimately show a different number in each.

Company	ROE	ROE change	Reported
Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. SLDE	17%	−4.1 pp	Mar 2026
The Progressive Corporation PGR	9.9%	−1.5 pp	Jun 2026
HCI Group, Inc. HCI	9.9%	−5.9 pp	Mar 2026
W. R. Berkley Corporation WRB	9.7%	+5.0 pp	Jun 2026
RLI Corp. RLI	9.6%	+2.1 pp	Jun 2026
Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. KNSL	9.4%	+0.4 pp	Jun 2026
The Allstate Corporation ALL	9.2%	+6.3 pp	Mar 2026
Mercury General Corporation MCY	8.6%	+14.9 pp	Mar 2026
The Travelers Companies, Inc. TRV	7.0%	+1.5 pp	Jun 2026
The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. THG	5.6%	+1.0 pp	Mar 2026
Old Republic International Corporation ORI	5.3%	+1.9 pp	Jun 2026
Assurant, Inc. AIZ	4.9%	+2.0 pp	Mar 2026
Palomar Holdings, Inc. PLMR	4.9%	−1.7 pp	Mar 2026
Skyward Specialty Insurance Group, Inc. SKWD	4.8%	−0.7 pp	Mar 2026
American Financial Group, Inc. AFG	4.2%	+0.6 pp	Mar 2026
Chubb Limited CB	3.7%	−0.6 pp	Jun 2026
Selective Insurance Group, Inc. SIGI	3.7%	+1.0 pp	Jun 2026
United Fire Group, Inc. UFCS	3.4%	+1.1 pp	Mar 2026
Horace Mann Educators Corporation HMN	2.9%	−0.1 pp	Mar 2026
Stewart Information Services Corporation STC	2.7%	+0.2 pp	Jun 2026
CNA Financial Corporation CNA	2.0%	−0.7 pp	Mar 2026
Cincinnati Financial Corporation CINF	1.9%	+2.6 pp	Mar 2026
Loews Corporation L	1.9%	−0.3 pp	Mar 2026
Kemper Corporation KMPR	-0.2%	−3.7 pp	Mar 2026
White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. WTM	-0.5%	−1.8 pp	Mar 2026
Markel Group Inc. MKL	-1.1%	−1.9 pp	Mar 2026
Safety Insurance Group, Inc. SAFT	-1.7%	−4.3 pp	Mar 2026
Hagerty, Inc. HGTY	-2.2%	−7.9 pp	Mar 2026
Lemonade, Inc. LMND	-6.7%	+3.5 pp	Mar 2026
Porch Group, Inc. PRCH	-67%	−57.6 pp	Mar 2026

Full 20-quarter history · every available company

ROE · reported quarter history

Showing the 12 largest of 30 companies with a series here. The remaining 18 are complete in the plain-text rendition and the trace payload — nothing is dropped from the data, only from this grid.

American Financial Group, Inc. · AFG

Sep 20213.8%

Dec 20216.0%

Mar 20225.0%

Jun 20223.5%

Sep 20223.6%

Dec 20226.1%

Mar 20234.8%

Jun 20235.0%

Sep 20234.5%

Dec 20236.3%

Mar 20245.9%

Jun 20245.0%

Sep 20244.2%

Dec 20245.8%

Mar 20253.6%

Jun 20253.9%

Sep 20254.6%

Dec 20256.4%

Mar 20264.2%

Jun 2026—

Assurant, Inc. · AIZ

Sep 202115%

Dec 20212.1%

Mar 20222.7%

Jun 20221.0%

Sep 20220.1%

Dec 20221.4%

Mar 20232.4%

Jun 20233.5%

Sep 20234.4%

Dec 20234.0%

Mar 20245.1%

Jun 20244.0%

Sep 20242.7%

Dec 20244.1%

Mar 20252.9%

Jun 20254.5%

Sep 20254.8%

Dec 20254.1%

Mar 20264.9%

Jun 2026—

Chubb Limited · CB

Sep 20213.2%

Dec 20213.6%

Mar 20223.4%

Jun 20222.1%

Sep 20221.5%

Dec 20222.4%

Mar 20233.4%

Jun 20233.4%

Sep 20233.9%

Dec 20235.8%

Mar 20243.9%

Jun 20243.8%

Sep 20243.9%

Dec 20244.0%

Mar 20252.0%

Jun 20254.3%

Sep 20254.2%

Dec 20254.3%

Mar 20263.1%

Jun 20263.7%

Cincinnati Financial Corporation · CINF

Sep 20211.4%

Dec 202113%

Mar 2022-2.3%

Jun 2022-7.3%

Sep 2022-3.9%

Dec 20228.6%

Mar 20232.0%

Jun 20234.9%

Sep 2023-1.0%

Dec 202310%

Mar 20246.5%

Jun 20242.6%

Sep 20246.7%

Dec 20243.1%

Mar 2025-0.7%

Jun 20255.1%

Sep 20257.7%

Dec 20254.5%

Mar 20261.9%

Jun 2026—

CNA Financial Corporation · CNA

Sep 20212.1%

Dec 20211.9%

Mar 20222.6%

Jun 20221.7%

Sep 2022-0.4%

Dec 20222.2%

Mar 20233.0%

Jun 20233.1%

Sep 20233.1%

Dec 20234.0%

Mar 20243.7%

Jun 20243.4%

Sep 20242.9%

Dec 20240.2%

Mar 20252.7%

Jun 20252.9%

Sep 20253.7%

Dec 20252.7%

Mar 20262.0%

Jun 2026—

Loews Corporation · L

Sep 20211.3%

Dec 20211.8%

Mar 20221.9%

Jun 20221.1%

Sep 2022-0.2%

Dec 20222.2%

Mar 20232.4%

Jun 20232.4%

Sep 20231.9%

Dec 20233.0%

Mar 20243.0%

Jun 20242.4%

Sep 20242.5%

Dec 20241.1%

Mar 20252.2%

Jun 20252.3%

Sep 20252.9%

Dec 20252.3%

Mar 20261.9%

Jun 2026—

Markel Group Inc. · MKL

Sep 20211.4%

Dec 20216.2%

Mar 2022-0.3%

Jun 2022-6.4%

Sep 20220.9%

Dec 20224.9%

Mar 20233.7%

Jun 20235.1%

Sep 20230.4%

Dec 20235.4%

Mar 20246.9%

Jun 20241.9%

Sep 20245.9%

Dec 20243.4%

Mar 20250.8%

Jun 20253.9%

Sep 20254.2%

Dec 20253.2%

Mar 2026-1.1%

Jun 2026—

Old Republic International Corporation · ORI

Sep 20211.4%

Dec 20219.6%

Mar 20224.6%

Jun 2022-0.6%

Sep 2022-1.5%

Dec 20227.8%

Mar 20233.1%

Jun 20232.5%

Sep 20230.9%

Dec 20233.0%

Mar 20245.0%

Jun 20241.5%

Sep 20245.5%

Dec 20241.7%

Mar 20254.0%

Jun 20253.4%

Sep 20254.3%

Dec 20253.6%

Mar 20265.6%

Jun 20265.3%

The Allstate Corporation · ALL

Sep 20212.0%

Dec 20212.9%

Mar 20222.6%

Jun 2022-4.2%

Sep 2022-3.0%

Dec 2022-1.4%

Mar 2023-1.6%

Jun 2023-7.8%

Sep 20230.0%

Dec 20238.5%

Mar 20246.7%

Jun 20242.0%

Sep 20246.6%

Dec 20249.7%

Mar 20252.9%

Jun 20259.9%

Sep 202516%

Dec 202515%

Mar 20269.2%

Jun 2026—

The Progressive Corporation · PGR

Sep 20210.6%

Dec 20215.5%

Mar 20221.8%

Jun 2022-3.2%

Sep 20220.7%

Dec 20224.8%

Mar 20232.6%

Jun 20232.1%

Sep 20237.0%

Dec 202311%

Mar 202412%

Jun 20247.3%

Sep 202411%

Dec 202410%

Mar 202510%

Jun 202511%

Sep 20258.4%

Dec 202511%

Mar 20269.2%

Jun 20269.9%

The Travelers Companies, Inc. · TRV

Sep 20212.4%

Dec 20214.6%

Mar 20223.8%

Jun 20222.1%

Sep 20221.9%

Dec 20223.2%

Mar 20234.0%

Jun 2023-0.1%

Sep 20232.0%

Dec 20237.0%

Mar 20244.7%

Jun 20242.3%

Sep 20245.3%

Dec 20247.9%

Mar 20251.5%

Jun 20255.5%

Sep 20256.4%

Dec 20258.2%

Mar 20265.7%

Jun 20267.0%

W. R. Berkley Corporation · WRB

Sep 20214.2%

Dec 20214.5%

Mar 20228.9%

Jun 20222.7%

Sep 20223.5%

Dec 20225.7%

Mar 20234.3%

Jun 20235.3%

Sep 20235.0%

Dec 20235.6%

Mar 20246.0%

Jun 20245.1%

Sep 20244.8%

Dec 20247.2%

Mar 20255.0%

Jun 20254.7%

Sep 20255.6%

Dec 20255.0%

Mar 20265.5%

Jun 20269.7%

ROE change · reported quarter history

Showing the 12 largest of 30 companies with a series here. The remaining 18 are complete in the plain-text rendition and the trace payload — nothing is dropped from the data, only from this grid.

American Financial Group, Inc. · AFG

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−0.2 pp

Dec 2022+0.1 pp

Mar 2023−0.2 pp

Jun 2023+1.5 pp

Sep 2023+0.9 pp

Dec 2023+0.2 pp

Mar 2024+1.1 pp

Jun 20240.0 pp

Sep 2024−0.3 pp

Dec 2024−0.5 pp

Mar 2025−2.3 pp

Jun 2025−1.1 pp

Sep 2025+0.4 pp

Dec 2025+0.6 pp

Mar 2026+0.6 pp

Jun 2026—

Assurant, Inc. · AIZ

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−15.0 pp

Dec 2022−0.7 pp

Mar 2023−0.3 pp

Jun 2023+2.5 pp

Sep 2023+4.3 pp

Dec 2023+2.6 pp

Mar 2024+2.7 pp

Jun 2024+0.5 pp

Sep 2024−1.7 pp

Dec 2024+0.1 pp

Mar 2025−2.2 pp

Jun 2025+0.5 pp

Sep 2025+2.1 pp

Dec 20250.0 pp

Mar 2026+2.0 pp

Jun 2026—

Chubb Limited · CB

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−1.7 pp

Dec 2022−1.2 pp

Mar 20230.0 pp

Jun 2023+1.3 pp

Sep 2023+2.4 pp

Dec 2023+3.4 pp

Mar 2024+0.5 pp

Jun 2024+0.4 pp

Sep 20240.0 pp

Dec 2024−1.8 pp

Mar 2025−1.9 pp

Jun 2025+0.5 pp

Sep 2025+0.3 pp

Dec 2025+0.3 pp

Mar 2026+1.1 pp

Jun 2026−0.6 pp

Cincinnati Financial Corporation · CINF

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−5.3 pp

Dec 2022−3.9 pp

Mar 2023+4.3 pp

Jun 2023+12.2 pp

Sep 2023+2.9 pp

Dec 2023+1.8 pp

Mar 2024+4.5 pp

Jun 2024−2.3 pp

Sep 2024+7.7 pp

Dec 2024−7.3 pp

Mar 2025−7.2 pp

Jun 2025+2.5 pp

Sep 2025+1.0 pp

Dec 2025+1.4 pp

Mar 2026+2.6 pp

Jun 2026—

CNA Financial Corporation · CNA

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−2.5 pp

Dec 2022+0.3 pp

Mar 2023+0.4 pp

Jun 2023+1.4 pp

Sep 2023+3.5 pp

Dec 2023+1.8 pp

Mar 2024+0.7 pp

Jun 2024+0.3 pp

Sep 2024−0.2 pp

Dec 2024−3.8 pp

Mar 2025−1.0 pp

Jun 2025−0.5 pp

Sep 2025+0.8 pp

Dec 2025+2.5 pp

Mar 2026−0.7 pp

Jun 2026—

Loews Corporation · L

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−1.5 pp

Dec 2022+0.4 pp

Mar 2023+0.5 pp

Jun 2023+1.3 pp

Sep 2023+2.1 pp

Dec 2023+0.8 pp

Mar 2024+0.6 pp

Jun 20240.0 pp

Sep 2024+0.6 pp

Dec 2024−1.9 pp

Mar 2025−0.8 pp

Jun 2025−0.1 pp

Sep 2025+0.4 pp

Dec 2025+1.2 pp

Mar 2026−0.3 pp

Jun 2026—

Markel Group Inc. · MKL

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−0.5 pp

Dec 2022−1.3 pp

Mar 2023+4.0 pp

Jun 2023+11.5 pp

Sep 2023−0.5 pp

Dec 2023+0.5 pp

Mar 2024+3.2 pp

Jun 2024−3.2 pp

Sep 2024+5.5 pp

Dec 2024−2.0 pp

Mar 2025−6.1 pp

Jun 2025+2.0 pp

Sep 2025−1.7 pp

Dec 2025−0.2 pp

Mar 2026−1.9 pp

Jun 2026—

Old Republic International Corporation · ORI

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−2.9 pp

Dec 2022−1.8 pp

Mar 2023−1.5 pp

Jun 2023+3.1 pp

Sep 2023+2.4 pp

Dec 2023−4.8 pp

Mar 2024+1.9 pp

Jun 2024−1.0 pp

Sep 2024+4.6 pp

Dec 2024−1.3 pp

Mar 2025−1.0 pp

Jun 2025+1.9 pp

Sep 2025−1.2 pp

Dec 2025+1.9 pp

Mar 2026+1.6 pp

Jun 2026+1.9 pp

The Allstate Corporation · ALL

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−5.0 pp

Dec 2022−4.3 pp

Mar 2023−4.2 pp

Jun 2023−3.6 pp

Sep 2023+3.0 pp

Dec 2023+9.9 pp

Mar 2024+8.3 pp

Jun 2024+9.8 pp

Sep 2024+6.6 pp

Dec 2024+1.2 pp

Mar 2025−3.8 pp

Jun 2025+7.9 pp

Sep 2025+8.9 pp

Dec 2025+5.0 pp

Mar 2026+6.3 pp

Jun 2026—

The Progressive Corporation · PGR

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022+0.1 pp

Dec 2022−0.7 pp

Mar 2023+0.8 pp

Jun 2023+5.3 pp

Sep 2023+6.3 pp

Dec 2023+6.2 pp

Mar 2024+9.5 pp

Jun 2024+5.2 pp

Sep 2024+3.5 pp

Dec 2024−0.7 pp

Mar 2025−2.0 pp

Jun 2025+4.1 pp

Sep 2025−2.1 pp

Dec 2025+0.3 pp

Mar 2026−0.9 pp

Jun 2026−1.5 pp

The Travelers Companies, Inc. · TRV

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−0.5 pp

Dec 2022−1.4 pp

Mar 2023+0.2 pp

Jun 2023−2.2 pp

Sep 2023+0.1 pp

Dec 2023+3.8 pp

Mar 2024+0.7 pp

Jun 2024+2.4 pp

Sep 2024+3.3 pp

Dec 2024+0.9 pp

Mar 2025−3.2 pp

Jun 2025+3.2 pp

Sep 2025+1.1 pp

Dec 2025+0.3 pp

Mar 2026+4.2 pp

Jun 2026+1.5 pp

W. R. Berkley Corporation · WRB

Sep 2021—

Dec 2021—

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022−0.7 pp

Dec 2022+1.2 pp

Mar 2023−4.6 pp

Jun 2023+2.6 pp

Sep 2023+1.5 pp

Dec 2023−0.1 pp

Mar 2024+1.7 pp

Jun 2024−0.2 pp

Sep 2024−0.2 pp

Dec 2024+1.6 pp

Mar 2025−1.0 pp

Jun 2025−0.4 pp

Sep 2025+0.8 pp

Dec 2025−2.2 pp

Mar 2026+0.5 pp

Jun 2026+5.0 pp

06 · not available

Gross NPA — Leaders & Improvers

No company in this Insurance - Property & Casualty comparison reports gross NPA on a comparable basis, so there is nothing to rank here — 0 of 30 companies have a usable current reading. The section is shown rather than removed so an unavailable metric is not mistaken for one that was quietly left out.

Lower gross NPA is better. Improvement means the ratio is falling, so ranks are intentionally inverted.

07 · compare level, then change

Valuation Against Growth & Quality

Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. has the lowest P/BV ÷ ROE among the 30 Insurance - Property & Casualty companies compared here, at 0.11×. The Allstate Corporation is next at 0.18×. Porch Group, Inc. has the lowest P/BV at -29.9×, so level and change sit with different companies. 23 of 30 companies report a comparable reading, the latest through Mar 2026.

What the numbers say: Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. has the lowest comparable P/BV ÷ ROE at 0.11×, 38.9% below The Allstate Corporation. Only 23 of 30 companies pass the guard, so no broad “cheapest stock” conclusion is defensible unless the current multiple, own-history position and growth durability agree.

LeaderSlide Insurance Holdings, Inc. · 0.11×

Gap38.9% versus #2 · The Allstate Corporation

Persistence0/4 recent comparable periods

Coverage23/30 companies · 446 observations

Investor read: Treat valuation as permission to investigate, never as a standalone reason to buy.

This conclusion weakens if: The next two comparable reports reverse the current p/bv signal.

Banks are compared on P/BV and P/BV÷ROE, not PEG. Lower is better only if asset quality and return durability hold; cheap book value with weakening NPAs is not automatically attractive.

P/BV ÷ ROElowest return-adjusted price

1Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. SLDE0.1

2The Allstate Corporation ALL0.2

3HCI Group, Inc. HCI0.2

4Mercury General Corporation MCY0.2

5W. R. Berkley Corporation WRB0.3

P/BVlowest P/BV

1Porch Group, Inc. PRCH-29.9

2Kemper Corporation KMPR0.7

3United Fire Group, Inc. UFCS1.0

4White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. WTM1.0

5CNA Financial Corporation CNA1.1

Valuation · company comparison

23/30 level · 30/30 change

Solid lines show level; dotted lines show change when “Both” is selected. Missing reports break the line rather than being invented.

All-company data · latest reported quarter

Each figure is the company’s latest single reported quarter. The rankings above use trailing-twelve-month or current-market values, so a company can legitimately show a different number in each.

Company	P/BV ÷ ROE	P/BV	Reported
Cincinnati Financial Corporation CINF	0.8	1.6	Mar 2026
Palomar Holdings, Inc. PLMR	0.7	3.3	Mar 2026
Hagerty, Inc. HGTY	0.6	4.9	Mar 2026
Loews Corporation L	0.6	1.2	Mar 2026
CNA Financial Corporation CNA	0.6	1.1	Mar 2026
Kemper Corporation KMPR	0.6	0.7	Mar 2026
Safety Insurance Group, Inc. SAFT	0.6	1.3	Mar 2026
American Financial Group, Inc. AFG	0.5	2.3	Mar 2026
Chubb Limited CB	0.5	1.8	Jun 2026
W. R. Berkley Corporation WRB	0.5	2.5	Jun 2026
Markel Group Inc. MKL	0.5	1.3	Mar 2026
Stewart Information Services Corporation STC	0.5	1.2	Jun 2026
Selective Insurance Group, Inc. SIGI	0.4	1.6	Jun 2026
Horace Mann Educators Corporation HMN	0.4	1.2	Mar 2026
The Progressive Corporation PGR	0.4	3.6	Jun 2026
Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. KNSL	0.4	3.7	Jun 2026
Assurant, Inc. AIZ	0.4	1.8	Mar 2026
Skyward Specialty Insurance Group, Inc. SKWD	0.3	1.6	Mar 2026
RLI Corp. RLI	0.3	3.1	Jun 2026
Old Republic International Corporation ORI	0.3	1.6	Jun 2026
The Travelers Companies, Inc. TRV	0.3	2.1	Jun 2026
The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. THG	0.3	1.7	Mar 2026
United Fire Group, Inc. UFCS	0.3	1.0	Mar 2026
Mercury General Corporation MCY	0.2	1.9	Mar 2026
The Allstate Corporation ALL	0.2	1.7	Mar 2026
HCI Group, Inc. HCI	0.2	1.8	Mar 2026
Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. SLDE	0.1	1.9	Mar 2026
White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. WTM	0.1	1.0	Mar 2026
Lemonade, Inc. LMND	—	9.3	Mar 2026
Porch Group, Inc. PRCH	—	-29.9	Mar 2026

Full 20-quarter history · every available company

P/BV ÷ ROE · reported quarter history

Showing the 12 largest of 28 companies with a series here. The remaining 16 are complete in the plain-text rendition and the trace payload — nothing is dropped from the data, only from this grid.

American Financial Group, Inc. · AFG

Sep 20210.5

Dec 20210.4

Mar 20220.5

Jun 20220.8

Sep 20220.7

Dec 20220.5

Mar 20230.6

Jun 20230.5

Sep 20230.5

Dec 20230.4

Mar 20240.5

Jun 20240.5

Sep 20240.6

Dec 20240.4

Mar 20250.7

Jun 20250.6

Sep 20250.6

Dec 20250.4

Mar 20260.5

Jun 2026—

Assurant, Inc. · AIZ

Sep 20210.1

Dec 20210.8

Mar 20220.7

Jun 20222.1

Sep 202218.7

Dec 20221.1

Mar 20230.6

Jun 20230.4

Sep 20230.4

Dec 20230.5

Mar 20240.4

Jun 20240.4

Sep 20240.7

Dec 20240.5

Mar 20250.7

Jun 20250.4

Sep 20250.4

Dec 20250.5

Mar 20260.4

Jun 2026—

Chubb Limited · CB

Sep 20210.4

Dec 20210.4

Mar 20220.5

Jun 20220.8

Sep 20221.1

Dec 20220.8

Mar 20230.5

Jun 20230.4

Sep 20230.4

Dec 20230.3

Mar 20240.5

Jun 20240.5

Sep 20240.5

Dec 20240.4

Mar 20250.9

Jun 20250.4

Sep 20250.4

Dec 20250.4

Mar 20260.6

Jun 20260.5

Cincinnati Financial Corporation · CINF

Sep 20211.1

Dec 20210.1

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022—

Dec 20220.2

Mar 20230.8

Jun 20230.3

Sep 2023—

Dec 20230.1

Mar 20240.2

Jun 20240.6

Sep 20240.2

Dec 20240.5

Mar 2025—

Jun 20250.3

Sep 20250.2

Dec 20250.4

Mar 20260.8

Jun 2026—

CNA Financial Corporation · CNA

Sep 20210.4

Dec 20210.5

Mar 20220.5

Jun 20220.8

Sep 2022—

Dec 20220.6

Mar 20230.4

Jun 20230.4

Sep 20230.4

Dec 20230.3

Mar 20240.4

Jun 20240.4

Sep 20240.4

Dec 20246.3

Mar 20250.5

Jun 20250.4

Sep 20250.3

Dec 20250.4

Mar 20260.6

Jun 2026—

Loews Corporation · L

Sep 20210.6

Dec 20210.4

Mar 20220.5

Jun 20220.9

Sep 2022—

Dec 20220.4

Mar 20230.4

Jun 20230.4

Sep 20230.5

Dec 20230.3

Mar 20240.4

Jun 20240.4

Sep 20240.4

Dec 20241.0

Mar 20250.5

Jun 20250.5

Sep 20250.4

Dec 20250.5

Mar 20260.6

Jun 2026—

Markel Group Inc. · MKL

Sep 20210.8

Dec 20210.2

Mar 2022—

Jun 2022—

Sep 20221.3

Dec 20220.3

Mar 20230.3

Jun 20230.3

Sep 20233.5

Dec 20230.2

Mar 20240.2

Jun 20240.7

Sep 20240.2

Dec 20240.4

Mar 20251.7

Jun 20250.4

Sep 20250.3

Dec 20250.5

Mar 2026—

Jun 2026—

Old Republic International Corporation · ORI

Sep 20210.8

Dec 20210.1

Mar 20220.3

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022—

Dec 20220.2

Mar 20230.4

Jun 20230.5

Sep 20231.4

Dec 20230.4

Mar 20240.3

Jun 20240.9

Sep 20240.3

Dec 20240.9

Mar 20250.4

Jun 20250.5

Sep 20250.4

Dec 20250.5

Mar 20260.3

Jun 20260.3

The Allstate Corporation · ALL

Sep 20210.7

Dec 20210.5

Mar 20220.6

Jun 2022—

Sep 2022—

Dec 2022—

Mar 2023—

Jun 2023—

Sep 2023—

Dec 20230.2

Mar 20240.4

Jun 20241.1

Sep 20240.4

Dec 20240.2

Mar 20250.9

Jun 20250.2

Sep 20250.1

Dec 20250.1

Mar 20260.2

Jun 2026—

The Progressive Corporation · PGR

Sep 20214.8

Dec 20210.6

Mar 20222.2

Jun 2022—

Sep 20226.6

Dec 20221.0

Mar 20231.9

Jun 20232.2

Sep 20230.7

Dec 20230.4

Mar 20240.5

Jun 20240.7

Sep 20240.5

Dec 20240.5

Mar 20250.6

Jun 20250.4

Sep 20250.5

Dec 20250.4

Mar 20260.4

Jun 2026—

The Travelers Companies, Inc. · TRV

Sep 20210.6

Dec 20210.3

Mar 20220.5

Jun 20220.8

Sep 20221.0

Dec 20220.6

Mar 20230.4

Jun 2023—

Sep 20230.9

Dec 20230.3

Mar 20240.5

Jun 20240.8

Sep 20240.4

Dec 20242.9

Mar 20251.4

Jun 20250.4

Sep 20250.3

Dec 20251.1

Mar 20260.3

Jun 20260.3

W. R. Berkley Corporation · WRB

Sep 20210.5

Dec 20210.5

Mar 20220.3

Jun 20221.0

Sep 20220.8

Dec 20220.5

Mar 20230.6

Jun 20230.4

Sep 20230.5

Dec 20230.4

Mar 20240.5

Jun 20240.5

Sep 20240.5

Dec 20240.4

Mar 20250.6

Jun 20250.6

Sep 20250.5

Dec 20250.6

Mar 20260.5

Jun 2026—

P/BV · reported quarter history

Showing the 12 largest of 30 companies with a series here. The remaining 18 are complete in the plain-text rendition and the trace payload — nothing is dropped from the data, only from this grid.

American Financial Group, Inc. · AFG

Sep 20212.0

Dec 20212.3

Mar 20222.6

Jun 20222.9

Sep 20222.7

Dec 20222.9

Mar 20232.6

Jun 20232.5

Sep 20232.4

Dec 20232.3

Mar 20242.7

Jun 20242.4

Sep 20242.4

Dec 20242.6

Mar 20252.5

Jun 20252.3

Sep 20252.6

Dec 20252.4

Mar 20262.3

Jun 2026—

Assurant, Inc. · AIZ

Sep 20211.6

Dec 20211.6

Mar 20222.0

Jun 20222.1

Sep 20221.9

Dec 20221.6

Mar 20231.5

Jun 20231.5

Sep 20231.7

Dec 20231.8

Mar 20242.0

Jun 20241.7

Sep 20241.9

Dec 20242.1

Mar 20252.0

Jun 20251.8

Sep 20251.9

Dec 20252.0

Mar 20261.8

Jun 2026—

Chubb Limited · CB

Sep 20211.3

Dec 20211.4

Mar 20221.6

Jun 20221.6

Sep 20221.6

Dec 20221.8

Mar 20231.5

Jun 20231.5

Sep 20231.6

Dec 20231.5

Mar 20241.7

Jun 20241.7

Sep 20241.8

Dec 20241.7

Mar 20251.8

Jun 20251.7

Sep 20251.6

Dec 20251.7

Mar 20261.7

Jun 20261.8

Cincinnati Financial Corporation · CINF

Sep 20211.6

Dec 20211.4

Mar 20221.8

Jun 20221.8

Sep 20221.5

Dec 20221.5

Mar 20231.6

Jun 20231.4

Sep 20231.5

Dec 20231.3

Mar 20241.5

Jun 20241.4

Sep 20241.5

Dec 20241.6

Mar 20251.7

Jun 20251.6

Sep 20251.6

Dec 20251.6

Mar 20261.6

Jun 2026—

CNA Financial Corporation · CNA

Sep 20210.9

Dec 20210.9

Mar 20221.2

Jun 20221.3

Sep 20221.2

Dec 20221.3

Mar 20231.2

Jun 20231.2

Sep 20231.2

Dec 20231.2

Mar 20241.3

Jun 20241.3

Sep 20241.2

Dec 20241.3

Mar 20251.3

Jun 20251.2

Sep 20251.1

Dec 20251.1

Mar 20261.1

Jun 2026—

Loews Corporation · L

Sep 20210.8

Dec 20210.8

Mar 20221.0

Jun 20220.9

Sep 20220.9

Dec 20221.0

Mar 20230.9

Jun 20230.9

Sep 20231.0

Dec 20231.0

Mar 20241.1

Jun 20241.0

Sep 20241.0

Dec 20241.1

Mar 20251.1

Jun 20251.1

Sep 20251.1

Dec 20251.2

Mar 20261.2

Jun 2026—

Markel Group Inc. · MKL

Sep 20211.2

Dec 20211.1

Mar 20221.4

Jun 20221.4

Sep 20221.2

Dec 20221.3

Mar 20231.2

Jun 20231.3

Sep 20231.4

Dec 20231.2

Mar 20241.3

Jun 20241.3

Sep 20241.2

Dec 20241.3

Mar 20251.4

Jun 20251.5

Sep 20251.3

Dec 20251.5

Mar 20261.3

Jun 2026—

Old Republic International Corporation · ORI

Sep 20211.1

Dec 20211.1

Mar 20221.2

Jun 20221.1

Sep 20221.1

Dec 20221.2

Mar 20231.2

Jun 20231.2

Sep 20231.3

Dec 20231.3

Mar 20241.3

Jun 20241.3

Sep 20241.4

Dec 20241.6

Mar 20251.6

Jun 20251.5

Sep 20251.6

Dec 20251.9

Mar 20261.6

Jun 20261.6

The Allstate Corporation · ALL

Sep 20211.4

Dec 20211.3

Mar 20221.7

Jun 20221.7

Sep 20221.9

Dec 20222.0

Mar 20231.7

Jun 20231.8

Sep 20232.0

Dec 20232.1

Mar 20242.5

Jun 20242.3

Sep 20242.4

Dec 20242.4

Mar 20252.5

Jun 20252.2

Sep 20252.0

Dec 20251.8

Mar 20261.7

Jun 2026—

The Progressive Corporation · PGR

Sep 20212.9

Dec 20213.3

Mar 20223.9

Jun 20224.3

Sep 20224.6

Dec 20224.8

Mar 20235.0

Jun 20234.6

Sep 20234.7

Dec 20234.6

Mar 20245.6

Jun 20245.2

Sep 20245.5

Dec 20245.5

Mar 20255.7

Jun 20254.8

Sep 20254.1

Dec 20254.4

Mar 20263.6

Jun 2026—

The Travelers Companies, Inc. · TRV

Sep 20211.3

Dec 20211.3

Mar 20221.7

Jun 20221.8

Sep 20221.8

Dec 20222.0

Mar 20231.7

Jun 20231.8

Sep 20231.9

Dec 20231.7

Mar 20242.1

Jun 20241.9

Sep 20241.9

Dec 202422.6

Mar 20252.1

Jun 20252.0

Sep 20252.0

Dec 20259.0

Mar 20261.9

Jun 20262.1

W. R. Berkley Corporation · WRB

Sep 20211.9

Dec 20212.2

Mar 20222.6

Jun 20222.8

Sep 20222.7

Dec 20222.8

Mar 20232.4

Jun 20232.2

Sep 20232.4

Dec 20232.4

Mar 20242.9

Jun 20242.6

Sep 20242.6

Dec 20242.7

Mar 20253.0

Jun 20253.0

Sep 20253.0

Dec 20252.7

Mar 20262.5

Jun 2026—

08 · let price answer last

Market action

United Fire Group, Inc. has the strongest one-year price move in Insurance - Property & Casualty at +102.1%. It also leads on Mansfield relative strength against the S&P 500 at +28%. 20 of 30 covered companies are above zero on that measure. Every line covers 314 weekly closes through 2026-07-28.

Every price line is indexed to 100 over the chosen window. Mansfield relative strength compares a price ratio with its own 52-week average; zero separates leadership from lagging.

Price and relative strength

Price is rebased to 100 inside the selected window. Pair ratio rebases each selected company against one chosen denominator.

Before the conclusion · check the blind spots

What can make this comparison misleading?

This Insurance - Property & Casualty comparison names 6 specific ways its own evidence can mislead, all listed below. All 30 companies here report on comparable dates, so no rank carries a stale marker. 2 of the 7 ranked sections have fewer than three usable current readings. A high growth rate can still be a low-base artefact.

Keep these limits visible

A high growth rate can be a low-base artefact. The page keeps level and change separate for that reason.
A high ROE can be manufactured with leverage. Read it beside ROA and asset quality.
The 4-Factor Sector Score ranks research priority, not portfolio action. Management quality, catalysts and risks need equally fresh evidence before capital is deployed.
An “all companies” line chart preserves completeness, but rank changes should be checked against reporting dates before drawing a conclusion.
Banks and lenders are not forced through operating-margin or ROCE comparisons; missing lender-specific fields remain visibly missing.
Thin comparisons: Funding base, Asset quality have fewer than three usable current readings.

09 · the complete set

Which companies are included?

All 30 companies in the canonical Insurance - Property & Casualty membership are listed below, largest market value first — nothing is silently dropped, even where a company reports too little to rank. The charts above default to a selective view; this register is the complete set, with each company's own latest reporting date beside it.

AHEAD means the company is beating the index by 5% or more over three months. LAGGING, FUNDAMENTALS UP means it is 20% or more behind over a year while its trailing twelve-month earnings grew 20% or more. Both rules are fixed and applied the same way in every sector.

Company	Market value	Price	Priced to	Latest fundamentals
Chubb Limited CBAHEAD	$140.2B	$364	2026-07-28	Jun 2026
The Progressive Corporation PGRAHEADLAGGING, FUNDAMENTALS UP	$127.6B	$220	2026-07-28	Jun 2026
The Travelers Companies, Inc. TRVAHEAD18/26 WEEKS	$82.9B	$397	2026-07-28	Jun 2026
The Allstate Corporation ALLAHEAD	$70.1B	$272	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
W. R. Berkley Corporation WRBAHEAD	$29.6B	$76.2	2026-07-28	Jun 2026
Cincinnati Financial Corporation CINFAHEAD	$28.3B	$183	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
Markel Group Inc. MKLAHEAD	$25.5B	$2,039	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
Loews Corporation L	$24.6B	$119	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
CNA Financial Corporation CNAAHEAD	$15.0B	$55.3	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
Assurant, Inc. AIZAHEAD	$14.0B	$283	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
American Financial Group, Inc. AFGAHEAD	$12.0B	$145	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
Old Republic International Corporation ORIAHEAD	$10.6B	$44.4	2026-07-28	Jun 2026
Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. KNSLAHEADLAGGING, FUNDAMENTALS UP	$8.4B	$370	2026-07-28	Jun 2026
The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. THGAHEAD18/26 WEEKS	$7.8B	$224	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
Mercury General Corporation MCYAHEAD18/26 WEEKS	$6.1B	$110	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
RLI Corp. RLIAHEADLAGGING, FUNDAMENTALS UP	$6.0B	$65.1	2026-07-28	Jun 2026
Selective Insurance Group, Inc. SIGIAHEAD	$5.6B	$94.4	2026-07-28	Jun 2026
White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. WTM	$5.4B	$2,203	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
Lemonade, Inc. LMNDAHEAD	$4.8B	$62.1	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
Hagerty, Inc. HGTYAHEAD	$4.2B	$12.2	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
Palomar Holdings, Inc. PLMRAHEAD	$3.8B	$143	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
Skyward Specialty Insurance Group, Inc. SKWDAHEAD	$2.5B	$62.8	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. SLDEAHEAD	$2.5B	$21.4	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
HCI Group, Inc. HCIAHEAD	$2.3B	$179	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
Horace Mann Educators Corporation HMNAHEAD	$2.1B	$52.5	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
Stewart Information Services Corporation STC	$2.1B	$69.5	2026-07-28	Jun 2026
Kemper Corporation KMPR	$1.8B	$30.9	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
Safety Insurance Group, Inc. SAFTAHEAD	$1.5B	$103	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
Porch Group, Inc. PRCHAHEAD	$1.4B	$12.6	2026-07-28	Mar 2026
United Fire Group, Inc. UFCSAHEAD25/26 WEEKS	$1.4B	$52.8	2026-07-28	Mar 2026

Evidence and freshness

How was this comparison built?

This comparison is built from the reported filings of 30 Insurance - Property & Casualty companies, normalized to a common $ scale and a shared quarter axis of up to 20 quarters each. Fundamentals run through Jun 2026 and market data through 2026-07-28.

FundamentalsThrough Jun 2026 · up to 20 quarters per company

Market dataThrough 2026-07-28 · weekly price and relative-strength history

Derived metricsGrowth, changes, CAPEX intensity, net debt, guarded PEG and P/BV÷ROE are calculated only when their inputs are comparable.

Score confidenceMissing and stale evidence reduces confidence and pulls the 0–100 research-priority score toward neutral.

Questions investors ask · short, speakable answers

Insurance - Property & Casualty company comparison FAQs

These 15 answers restate the Insurance - Property & Casualty comparison above in question form. Every one is computed from the same 30 companies and the same reported filings as the rankings and charts, current through Jun 2026. Price and relative-strength answers run through 2026-07-28. Nothing here is estimated, and none of it is a recommendation.

Which Insurance - Property & Casualty company is the biggest?

The Allstate Corporation is the largest, with trailing-twelve-month income of $68,174 million, ahead of Loews Corporation at $18,515 million. That covers 21 of 30 companies with comparable reporting through Mar 2026.

Which Insurance - Property & Casualty company is growing fastest?

White Mountains Insurance Group, Ltd. has the fastest income growth at 69.3% year on year, across 21 of 30 comparable companies. Fast growth off a small base is not the same as proven scale — check whether the rate holds across several quarters on the chart above before treating it as a trend.

Which Insurance - Property & Casualty company makes the most profit?

The Allstate Corporation earns the most, at $12,128 million of trailing-twelve-month net profit, from 21 of 30 comparable companies. The Allstate Corporation has the fastest profit growth at 100%, though growth off a small or recovering profit base overstates how much has actually changed.

Which Insurance - Property & Casualty company earns the highest return on capital?

Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. leads on return on assets at 5.8%, across 28 of 30 companies. Read it beside the length of its reported history: a high return that repeats for years is evidence of a durable business, while a single high reading can be a small capital base or one good year.

Which Insurance - Property & Casualty stock is the cheapest?

On price-to-book divided by return on equity — where a LOWER number is cheaper — Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. screens cheapest at 0.11×. Only 23 of 30 companies pass the comparability guard, so this is not a sector-wide "cheapest stock" verdict. Cheap on a multiple is a reason to investigate, never a reason to buy on its own.

Is the Insurance - Property & Casualty sector beating the market?

Insurance - Property & Casualty has outperformed S&P 500 by 6.4% over the last 52 weeks and 14.1% over 13 weeks, measured on an equal-weight index of its current members. Inside the sector, 20 of 30 covered companies are beating the market on their own. Sector strength does not transfer evenly to every stock in it.

Which Insurance - Property & Casualty stock has the strongest price momentum?

United Fire Group, Inc. has the strongest relative strength against S&P 500. Relative strength answers last, after growth, quality and valuation: price can move well before the fundamentals confirm it, and sometimes without them confirming at all.

Which Insurance - Property & Casualty company scores highest for research priority?

Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. scores 75.4 out of 100 with 70% evidence confidence, from 24.7 points on growth and earnings, 20.8 on capital efficiency, 14.5 on valuation and 15.4 on relative strength. This ranks what deserves work next. It is not a buy recommendation, and management quality, catalysts and risk still need separate research.

How many Insurance - Property & Casualty companies does this comparison cover, and over what period?

It compares 30 listed companies over up to 20 reported quarters of fundamentals and 6 fiscal years of capital allocation, ending Jun 2026, plus weekly price and relative-strength history. Membership is the full sector list — nothing is dropped for having thin data.

What is the total market cap of the Insurance - Property & Casualty sector?

The 30 Insurance - Property & Casualty companies on this page carry $650,022 million of combined market value. Chubb Limited is the largest at $140,178 million, about 22% of the sector's total on its own. Market value moves with price, so this reading is dated 2026-07-28.

What is the Insurance - Property & Casualty sector's P/B ratio?

The median price-to-book ratio across the 30 Insurance - Property & Casualty companies on this page is 1.7×, measured on the 29 that report a comparable figure. A sector-level history for this multiple is not held here, so this is a cross-section of today, not a comparison with the sector’s own past. Figures are as of 2026-07-28.

How is the Insurance - Property & Casualty sector performing?

20 of the 30 covered Insurance - Property & Casualty companies are beating S&P 500 on Mansfield relative strength. The sector itself is 6.4% ahead of S&P 500 over 52 weeks on an equal-weight index of its current members. Readings are as of 2026-07-28.

How many Insurance - Property & Casualty stocks are listed in the US?

This comparison covers 30 listed Insurance - Property & Casualty companies in the US, each above the size floor the site applies. The full ranked list is on this page, with reported fundamentals through Jun 2026. Membership is the full industry list — nothing is dropped for having thin data.

Why are some values on this page blank?

A blank means that company did not report a comparable figure for that period, so nothing is shown. Missing observations are never interpolated, carried forward, or replaced with a similar-looking accounting line, and a company with missing evidence has its research score pulled toward neutral rather than being scored as bad.

Is this investment advice?

No. Every figure here is a deterministic calculation from reported company filings and market data, published for research. It contains no recommendation to buy or sell any security, does not account for your circumstances, and is not a substitute for advice from a licensed adviser.